Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Ehmagawd last night I watched the most God-awful drama in my life

I left the hall feeling extremely emotionally and mentally disturbed.

And I wasn't the only one. You could positively feel the disgust rippling through the audience at the drama that had just unfolded, as well as the relief that, thank God, it was finally over. I swear, a parent was even heard consoling her young children, insisting that none of it was real.

Damn, it was seriously disturbing.

I'm just glad that not many people were in the audience to witness this horrific drama. You see, that night, there were two dramas, or "amateur productions", being acted out by two classes taking Drama this semester. As it was basically an assignment, with 25 marks allocated to it, there was no hype, promotion or posters about it. Heck, there weren't even any doorkeepers outside to welcome us.

Since I'm obviously not taking Drama or even BENL (contrary to popular belief, I am a Sociology student), I only found out about it from my Sciences of Qur'an classmate. Call me curious, but overhearing the words "toga" and "drama" mentioned in one breath totally piqued my interest. Dude, it sounded cooool. So I promptly invited Kim and Nazriq to watch the drama when I met them for lunch.

The aforementioned toga was present in the first drama entitled Lysistrata, which, thank God, was not as emotionally taxing and disturbing as the second one. Because, seriously, a girl can take only that many doses of The Creepy in one night without cracking up. But have no fear; I still have my gripes regarding the first one.

The theme of the first drama was clearly women's rights. Okay, no surprises there, since BENL is positively bursting at the seams with estrogen power. The play was set in Greece, and it was about the war between Athens and Sparta. The husbands wanted war, the wives wanted peace (naturally). So how did the women make a stand? By withholding sex from their husbands as long as the poor dicks continued to fight in war.

Urm, hello? What are they trying to say? That women can only use sex appeal to get their way? Gee, am I the only person smacking my forehead right now?

They even had a scene where one of the husbands fruitlessly tries to have sex with his wife. He even bemoans his neglected "little member". Just so you know, there were children in the audience. And this was held in an Islamic university.

I know it was supposed to be a Greek play, but they could have at least substituted some of the lines to make it sound less... I don't know… pagan? Like 'oh Zeus!' to 'Astarghfillahalazim!' and 'alcohol' to 'sparkling ribena' and ‘sacrifice’ to ‘slaughter’. Just a suggestion. And the whole sex scene? Come on, you don't have to stoop to crude sex jokes to coax a few laughs out of the audience.

I get that, just because we're in an Islamic university, it doesn't mean we have to drench our dramas with Islamic values. But this drama, and especially the second drama, was positively anti-Islam. That, I cannot accept.

Acting-wise, there's not much to say about Lysistrata. The leading actress outshone the rest, and I give her props for being able to memorise such a lengthy script, while infusing personality into it. Good voice projection and sassy intonation, but some of the lines were hard to catch as she was speaking so fast. A few of the other cast members, however, should have come equipped with subtitles; they were speaking as if they were in an overly dramatised Venezuelan telenovela. As for the chorus of Old Men (ironically played by Young Girls); Adilah you should give them some choral-speaking tips. The six of them weren't speaking in time, which made their scenes a whole waste as nobody could understand what they were saying. It was like listening to a bunch of noisy, castrated old men.

Kudos to the wardrobe manager, though. The costumes were a fantastic assortment of colours and really eye-catching. Boob-emphasising, though, but I guess we can't have everything, innit?

Overall, it was messy and draggy, but the jokes scattered around and, of course, the lead actress, saved the drama. I think we all sighed in relief when we realized the drama was over.

Until we realized that there was another drama to be shown. You should have seen the horror dawning comically in our eyes, as well as the desperate, pleading hope that it would be at least entertaining. It wasn’t so much to ask for, right? When the MC announced a ten-minute break before the next play would start, we all desperate scrambled out of the hall and ran to the convenience store to replenish our chocolate stockpile like deprived, PMS-y maniacs.

But, as it turned out, chocolate (or yoghurt and sweets, in Kim’s case) was not enough to prepare us for the traumatizing disaster that would unfold before our very eyes.

It started out very ominously, with the MC mysteriously neglecting to mention the title of the play or even explaining what it was about. Hey, throw us a crumb, why don’t you? We would have even appreciated an “Untitled 1” – at least have a name for your drama, regardless how lame it is. We had no idea whether it would be a period drama, a Shakespeare adaptation, or a feel-good play. The only clue we were given, unintentionally of course, was that the actors were dressed in normal clothes. Not much of a clue, if you ask me. At least Lysistrata prepared “programme books” for us, with a summary of the play. That is, if you can call an A4 paper with the names of the cast all spelt wrongly and the words “Hope You Enjoyed” gracing the back cover a "programme book". Sorry, but I expected more from students of Bachelor of English. But I give you an A for effort.

Because we had absolutely no idea what the drama was about, when two actresses come on stage – one dressed like a man in suit and pants, but with tudung, and the other dressed like, well, someone who should star on What Not To Wear – and were acting like they were married, well, it’s absolutely natural that we’d assume they’re a lesbian couple. Right?

Until the fashion victim (can’t remember her name) refers to the other actress as Edward. Hurm. Methinks the writer of this drama is very smitten by a certain sparkly vampire. We can safely assume from his name that Husband Edward is perfect.

I can’t remember much from the first scene because the lines were as draggy as a thesis. Just that Fashion Victim Wife received a threatening letter, and Husband Edward assures her that Everything’s Fine, now go waste time gossiping about Jimmy Choo's with your shallow girlfriends, you whiny, callous woman. And so she does. I remember the name Martin being thrown around, but I cannot for the life of me recall the relevance of that name to the whole drama.

The second scene was dragged out too long as well. Four ladies gossiping at a table over lunch. I interpreted each one of them as the Overdramatic Queen, The Voice of Reason, The Metropolitan Femme Fatale, and the Fashion Victim Wife. (Personally, the whole setting struck a disturbingly familiar chord in me afterwards. Must find out who the writer of this drama is.) Gossip ensues, until Husband Edward turns up to join the ladies.

Are you bored yet? Because I definitely was, especially as my chocolate stock was depleted and I was running solely on the sweet Kim offered me.

In the next scene, The Metroplitan Femme Fatale, (who, by the way, is easily the best actress in the whole play and whose talents were completely wasted on a minor role that had the potential to be the starring role, for God’s sake) amps up the sex-ay charm on Edward, and even seduces him into holding a few of her many shopping bags. So! Scandalous! Meanwhile, Overdramatic Queen and Voice of Reason watch from afar. Voice of Reason insists on being rational and says they’re “just friends”, while Overdramatic Queen hyperventilates in delight and calls up Fashion Victim Wife. Long, boring telephone call with inappropriate stressing on the wrong words ensues. As well as a lot of weird body twitching.

From this point onwards, the rest of the play is just about Edward and his wife. Seriously. None of the other characters turn up ever again. And you know what the worst part of that fact is? Kim, Naz and I decided to stay for the rest of the play only because we wanted to support one of the actresses, who is our friend. But she never came on stage again. What the eff?!

Anyways, on with the drama! The married couple fight. Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawn. The only memorable part was when Fashion victim wife screams something along the lines of “you’re having an affair with her because I’m fat and she’s thin?” Believe it or not, someone in the audience replies with a resounding YES. I smirk for a multitude of reasons too complex to explain here.

In the next scene, the wife attempts to commit suicide. I kid you not. I actually blurted out “what the f*ck?!” when I saw it. It wasn’t artsy or cool or even meaningful. The wife had a pizza-cutter by her wrist as she gurgled and giggled about killing herself, Edward, or/and Femme Fatale while uber-disturbing, freaky, tinkling, music-box lullaby played in the background.

One parent closed the eyes of her child. Another family actually left the hall. Yes, it was that disturbing. And in more ways than one. The wife was slowly chanting “tick-tock, tick-tock” as she was about to kill herself. Holy macaroni, I felt like puking there and then. I’m sorry, but what type of mind comes up with this kind of scene? And what type of mind considers it acceptable to perform such a graphic and sinful act in an Islamic university in front of families and children? I was deeply disturbed by the scene, and I swear I wasn’t the only one.

So the wife is sent to the mental hospital, where she is diagnosed of having split personality and even writing the threatening letter. But not before she gives a ridiculous, bloated, twisted, self-absorbed monologue that was clearly not only painful to the audience, but to the poor actress herself.

Everyone burst into laughter laced with desperation when the wife, husband and doctor walked off stage at the end of the scene. It wasn’t supposed to be funny, and it wasn’t even remotely funny. But we laughed. We laughed because we wanted to relieve ourselves from this uncalled-for suffering. I don't think any one of us unsuspecting audience truly deserved to be tortured this way.

In the next scene, everyone (meaning Edward and his wife, because only they matter, since all the other characters have been discarded so carelessly a long, long time ago) is happy.

Then suddenly, Edward discovers another threatening letter. "Oh no!" He/She groans, along with the rest of the audience. Then, the worst thing happens; the wife appears, holding out her right hand in front of her, her wrist clearly drenched in blood, as she calls out "Ed-waaaaard" hauntingly.

The audience is incredulous. I am incredulous. We shout and we groan and we even laugh, because this is just too unbelievable. It has long crossed the line of absurdity, and is deeply entrenched into the valley of poo.

As we are positively choking with indignation and disbelief, suddenly the MC's voice floods the hall: "we hope you enjoyed the drama tonight...."

No way. No effing way. That's it?

*Added on 24th March, 9:57pm:

Comments are henceforth disabled from this post


Thank you to everyone for taking your time to read and comment on my review :-) Again, I apologise for any feelings that have been hurt from my writings.

The reason I am henceforth disabling comments is because I gave the production crew the opportunity to meet me face-to-face and express whatever is on their mind (as clearly, judging from the comments, there's a lot of pent-up anger going on here). Unfortunately, you didn't take the chance. Too bad.

To everyone else who enjoyed reading my review and found the comments as hilarious as I did, do wait for my upcoming blog post, in which I shall be giving awards to the best comments! Among the categories will be:

Best Comment In A Foreign Language

Most "Insafable" Comment

Most Off-Topic Comment

Best Neutral Comment

and more! :D Stay tuned!*

*Added on 20th March 2009, 4.31pm: From now on, comments are moderated. Comments which do not reveal your true identity or email are automatically deleted, regardless of what you say. That means, comments by "Anonymous" or "A-T" or "Anime Freak" or other nicknames that don't reveal who you are will NOT be approved. If you really want your voice to be heard by everyone, reveal yourself and be proud of who you are and what you're saying! It's only fair :)*

130 comments:

anak pak man said...

I didn't catch the play, but from my reading, you writing about it kicks its ass so hard it landed on the moon (not unlike the "kopi kapal api" advert on TV). Again, brill stuff.. too bad we adoring, eager fans have to wait a coupla weeks for a post.. lurf yeah!

Anonymous said...

oh how Islamic of you to write this. you don't bash ppl you don't know. if you're saying that you're criticizing, then obviously you have NEVER read a review.
it's obvious you don't even understand both plays. LYSISTRATA IS AN EFFING MASTERPIECE and the jokes AREN'T made up. it's IN the play. go ahead and read it.
and for the second drama, the lecturer APPROVED of it from the start. and the lecturer is WAYYYY qualified than you are.
oh you expect ppl to welcome you at the door? oh come on this is just an assignment! you're not queen elizabeth for goodness sake.
and you said that the plays are staged by amateurs. so what can you expect??? this is not some istana budaya play dammit. of course there are flaws.
oh how nice of you to stay. did you really hate it? because looking at the way you're over-analyzing things, you seemed to be in love with both plays. oh how NICE of you.
so THIS is ISLAMIC huh? bashing ppl out of nowhere? yes yes. how ISLAMIC of you.

Anonymous said...

okashii no hito nee?
omae wa hime ka?
baka bakashi no hito!
buto no hito ka?
omae no karada wa hontou debu da kara urusai yo!!!
Bukkorosu, baka no hito!

Akmal said...

Holy macaroni! LOL. That's my first time hearing people use that one as expletive alright? Gotta adopt that one in my daily conversation lah hehehee :D
Too bad your night was a horror.

Anonymous said...

Haha.. anonymous #2 was obviously involved with the play and can't accept the fact that when you produce a play, you have to be prepared to terima the criticisms, no matter how harsh they are.

So Anisah didnt like the play. That's entirely her own right, and there's nothing wrong with that. Over analysing things doesnt mean you love it. Anisah probably has a lot to say because that's what happens when you feel a rush of passionate emotion- negative or otherwise.

Don't condemn people who hate a certain production, even if you say the production is 'critically acclaimed' or whatever.

Anonymous said...

Anisah, what a wonderful review/critic/ bashing(quoting from anonymous #1). To anonymous who i assume is involved in the play...eventhough the lecturer approved it, if it's against the Islamic teaching you should stop from staging it because you are a Muslim studying in an Islamic uni. Would u eat your own poop if your lecturer who happened to be more qualified ask u to do it? I assume u would, since u are so dependent on your lecturer and Lysistrata as a masterpiece (that is btw, agreed by the western/pagan thinkers/enthusiasts)....and u believe in that, ergo it makes u a masterpoopyy

Anonymous said...

I too am thoroughly disturbed with these sort of plays poisoning our minds and soul. Honestly, as a former BEN student myself, I don't understand why my fellow coursemates think that by performing something controversial and unIslamic (or both) it makes them more 'happening' or more 'artsy'. Unfortunately Anisah, if you speak to Ben students who are like-minded like me, they too wish that the theatre scene is not populated with B-grade minds who pretend to be intellectuals and creative to mask their shallow minds concerned with being popular. May Allah save us! Please write more to 'sedar' us.

Anonymous said...

Congratulations, you have just pissed 40+ people for the sake of attention. I hope it's worth it.

How thoughtful of you and indeed, how 'Islamic'. You are such an embarassment for UIA students. If you preach about being Islamic, why not actually practice it? If you have nothing nice to say, why say it again and again, just for the heck of it? If you don't like something, advise. Instead, all I see is endless bashing from the actors to the way they dress. You stress on being Islamic but you are such a poor example of a Muslim from this post. What are you trying to achieve? To be the most hated HS student? I think you are almost there.

Lysistrata is about a Greek play about how the Greek wives used their sexuality in order to keep their husbands from going to war. How is that unIslamic? They're married! And none of the actors show physical contact despite the plotline. And they are being graded for performing the original play. They are graded for memorizing their lines. Obviously they couln't change the lines. You went to a Greek play, you get a Greek play. If you wanted to watch a Greek play being mutilated by your nonsense suggestions, why not make your own production, then? How is this even an issue?

You didn't even explain how the second drama is anti-Islamic. You just state it is. This, to me, is blasphemous. Accusing someone being anti-Islamic without proof.


If you really disliked the play, why not try a bit of constructive criticism instead of just going on and on how horrible it is? This is an obviously biased post. You didn't even state how they could improve or what is positive part of the play even how small. Instead, you diss and diss. Your bitterness is so obvious. Your immaturity reeks from every word. Your stupidity is the foundation of this whole post. You are so incredibly rude I wonder how did you even make friends.

The 5th and 6th commenter is obviously a friend of Anisah who is incredibly blind or pretend to be blind to her actions. Or a fan who only knows how to kiss ass. Excuse me but from the way I see it, there is no constructive criticism at all. If she doesn't like it, then state why in a helpful manner or at least, nicely. But no, she just slammed everything in sight even though she herself has no knowledge about plays. And we are supposed to listen to this person who only knows how to insult with zero knowledge of what she speak of? Please. I can't even respect her as a person let alone listen to her. This whole post shows me what a horrible person you really are.

Even more sadly, there are actually some of her friends taking part in the plays. Are they still your friends now? How could they be when you just trash all their hardwork in just a few words? You are a selfish inconsiderate person. What kind of person are you who is willing to insult your own friends for the sake of a blog post? To all her other friends, what makes you think she won't do the same to you? It's pretty obvious the only thing she cares about is her blog and herself.

Well, at least we know now, Anisah Shurfa, how you really are. How you TRULY are. Just a naive, immature,desperately seeking attention nobody. We know now that you are just a trash-talking attention-whore.

If she has the right to express herself, we have the right to express ourselves too. Oh, and we will, I will grant you that. We condemn people who are inconsiderate and selfish and rude and downright stupid.

I hope you can bear the consequences. You deserve it from every word you just written. Good luck.

Mdm Azimah said...

Anisah, you have once again written a frank piece of writing that is too honest that is has offended some who may have eaten chilli and choked on the heat.
I plea to BEN students who will read this, or have yet to read this, be mindful of what you stage to the public.
Nevermind what literary masterpiece your chosen play is based on, in the end, you have the sole responsibility to answer to what purpose you staged it. Was it to entertain, to educate, to spread a message? And to whom are you staging this for? Most importantly, in the midsts of writing, creating or staging, we ought to remember that our main purpose is to do it for God. That's what sets our course different from other Eng Lit courses offered at other uni.
Otherwise, be prepared to have your adaptation be compared to other adaptations staged by other world-ranked (but respectfully secular) universities--that would definitely put us in our place, no more 'syok sendiri' for us!
Yes, there is a dilemma--how to Islamicise what is not Islamic in the first place? Well Ben students, that's your challenge, that's your purpose. Let's be creative, self-reflective and in the words of God, 'Read, in the Name of Allah!' (Al-Alaq).

Nina said...

Tut tut! So vengeful and angry some people can be. Let's have peace people.

Anisah is only voicing out her opinion. Let's take some of Anisah's comments as valid even though it hurts because, in the words of somebody I can't remember, 'the most honest person in the world is our enemy'.

If there's a lesson for anyone reading out there, be ready for some hard-hitting criticisms and be ready to learn from it, not fall from it.

Hafifah said...

Salam!
Why oh why are some people attacking a reviewer, and when the reviewer is being attacked on such a personal level, it is only fair that they disclose their identity instead of opting for 'anonymous'. The reviewer certainy is not hiding her true name and identity.

Anyway, agree with what Mdm said. It's exactly what all the Mdms at Matric say when we took drama/poetry etc at Matric, that is, do not stage/do/imitate things blindly--we are UIA students not blind mouse.

Makes me want to write a masterpiece myself now--not ones written by celebrated jahils, but ones that reflect my proud identity.

Perhaps Anisah and some of her mates can write also?

Nazriq said...

Wow, long post Anisah, and a lot of comments too... I was there watching the two dramas as well, and I am going to post my own take on it as soon as I finish all my assignments and reports. Anyway, the posts and comments here demand some opinion from me... I'll write my opinion on the whole event, as well as my opinion on the comments given.

First of all, regarding the plays. So there was no reception whatsoever, and there were technical problems here and there, and it was indeed messy. I have to admit that. It's a shame, because being from an Islamic university, we have to at least be courteous to those who come, but I feel that the committee have treated us audience rather coldly. But I can't say much, I give them the benefit of doubt, possibly they have a lot of assignments and reports to do, given that the semester is going to end soon.

The first play was deemed non-Islamic because of the elements it had. I recall the emcee herself saying that the play staged is an 'adaptation'. So if it is an adaptation, therefore, you have the right to adapt things to suit the situation, and in this case, make it more suitable for the Islamic audience, right? What's sad is that not only are there ridiculously obscene sexual references ('little member', lubricant, etc) and overly 'sexy' costumes which emphasize the boobs, but worst of all is the portrayal of alcohol. I'm no IRK student, but from my little understanding, it's not just the consumption of alcohol which is prohibited, but also working with a company which produces alcohol, or being associated with it in ANY way, either direct or indirect. However, I give props to the actors for taking the effort to memorize the INSANELY lengthy lines!

As for the 2nd drama, Anisah might not have stated why it's non-Islamic, but just by reading through (and for me, watching it), the non-Islamic elements are rather obvious. Suicide, the main theme of the play, is the single, most non-Islamic element I have never expected to see in a play in this campus. Not only was suicide portrayed at least THREE times in the play, there was not even a resolution or solution presented. In Islam, the very thought of suicide can cause Syirik, so think of what the portrayal of suicide can do to our minds. Do remember that in the audience, there were parents and young children as well. Even someone of my age finds such gory detail disturbing!

Now, on to my opinions regarding the comments.

Anonymous #1: Anisah is not bashing, she is merely stating her opinion. How exactly could you say she has NEVER read a review? Seeing that you're defending the play means that you're a BENL student, and I'm sure our writing lecturer has taught us on how to identify writing traits and sources of influences and such. I assume you have never stumbled upon top review sites such as rottentomatoes.com, which at first read, seems to be an obvious influence on Anisah's review style (please correct me if I'm wrong. Regarding Lysistrata, what evidence do have to prove that it's a masterpiece? To state something is masterpiece requires concrete evidence.

Also, just because your lecturer approved it means that he or she is right. He or she could be a twisted lecturer. Ponder on this: your lecturer asks you to eat crap, so are you going to eat crap? It doesn't take qualification to tell if something is bad or good, it takes MATURITY.

Anonymous #2: It isn't nice to say someone is stupid and ask someone to shut up in Japanese, assuming people will not understand. Whether you decide to use French or Japanese or Arabic or even Swahili, if you're going to curse, it's still a curse, you know?

Anonymous #5: I am a BENL student myself too, and I do not understand what's with the majority of BENL students' fascination with secular values and such. It amazes me that they seem to want to use as few Islamic values as possible, which is just really sad.

Anonymous #6: In what is Anisah an embarrassment? To me, sorry if this is harsh (I am a BENL student myself), but I believe the plays are not only an embarrassment to BENL (for being non-Islamic), but also an embarrassment to our university, and Muslim students as a whole. What Anisah is trying to do with this post is to show an insight on what is really happening, and on Muslims, instead of diss-cussing (aka dissing + cussing), we should be working on solutions on how to make things better.

Anisah is giving constructive criticism in a very indirect, subtle way. She wants us to think of what has become of us Muslims. Let me ask you, if a teacher blatantly points out the mistake of a student, you think the student will simply listen to it that easily?

Mdm Azimah: Can't agree more, madam!

The worst thing the plays have ever done to me, though, is that it made me question why am I in BENL. For a moment, I'm actually embarrassed to be one. I'd rather be called an IIUM student from now onwards.

Just what happened to Triple ICE and all those stuff which were told to us during the taa'ruf...

Sigh~

Anonymous said...

Anonymous #6...i assume you are a BENL student for you are defending so much of your course eventhough sometimes your coursemates and even your lecturer (some) are very twisted. What u need is to take a chill pill..everybody in UIA know how some BENL students would like to be associated with being Western. Btw, western here is not refering to geographical location but the adherence to the UNISLAMIC principles. Why on earth you as an Islamic University students would like to adhere to UNISLAMIC principles. U are such a disgrace to the University. The way i look at your commemnt as if that u have a personal grudge against Anisah.
Listen to MDM Azimah comment. This is sumthing good since it is an effort to cleanse the image of BENL students which have long thought as UNISLAMIC. My comment is definitely biased but asked the half of UIA what they think abt BENL courses and BENL students.

Anonymous said...

It is obvious that everyone here either has a prejudice against BENL students or has no idea what the assignment was about. I am also suprised that some people actually took Anisah's word for the play WITHOUT ACTUALLY WATCHING IT. What happened to fairness? Since when does a one-sided biased post is considered a literary review? What happened to listening to both sides? A real review is NEUTRAL. I refuse to believe that everyone who reads Anisah's blog is just sheep who listens to anything she says.

An anonymous commenter said that UIA students are not blind followers, which to me, is simply ironic as you are doing it right now. Have a little critical-thinking, please. What makes you think that everything she blogged in her is the true portrayal of the event? She herself admitted at the homepage of her blog that she adds embellishment to her blog posts whenever necessary to 'spice' things up. What makes you think this is not one of it? Most of the commenters here had never SEEN the actual play but agreed unanimously that the play is horrible and Anisah is right. I am sorry but your comments are not valid then as it is baseless.How can the cast members of the play not be enraged? If this were your play, wouldn't you be enraged as well? As the previous anonymous had said, there is no constructive criticisms. How are we supposed to even take this as a piece of advice?

Dear Madam Azimah, with all due respect, I have to disagree with some of your words. Yes, indeed we have to think about what we portray in our play. But we are reenacting an already written Greek play. This was our assignment. We are being graded to do it. Despite what everybody's notion of the play, the most important person to impress here is our lecturer who decided the play for us. This was intended for our class. Lysistrata is in our syllabus. What we did was simply follow the script which is part of our syllabus anyways.

If this is an issue to some of the people in UIA who does not understand Greek theatre, then please file a complaint instead of just rattling nonsense on their blogs and creating more and more prejudice against BENL students.


I have no idea if we have a course of eating crap. I also don't know how eating crap relates to BENL. The assignment was for a Drama class staging a Greek play which we all have learned. If our lecturer had asked to eat crap, we would have filed a complaint to the DD instead of just complaining in our blogs.


The second drama is anti-Islamic? First of all, the characters aren't even Muslims. Their names were Jessica and Nikki etc. Second of all, the person was not committing suicide. I am not sure whether both of you (referring to Anisah and Nazriq) were absent during this scene but the play itself had explained that the main character has a psychological disorder which is split personality. She does not know she is hurting herself. How is having a mental disorder unIslamic? There are probably tons of patients out there with the same problem and are Muslims.

For the technical difficulties faced in the play, it is easier to explain. We do NOT have committees. Some of the classes are actually ordered to have every member of the group to act onstage. How are we supposed to greet you when we can't bein two places at once? And I have no idea how to explain that this is a CLASS production that so happened to be staged in Main Audi. It didn't matter if there was any audience or not. The lecturer simply wants us to experience the process of producing a play. Hence, we produced the play for the lecturers and for knowledge. If you wanted to come and watch, then that is entirely up to you. But we hold no responsibility in anything you faced during the play. If you wanted a real presentation of a play, we would have charged you to pay the cost of producing a production and have actual committee members.

Constructive criticism in a subtle way? Saying that she wanted to puke while watching is subtle or even constructive? Swearing 'what the fuck' at our play is constructive? In the second drama, she said the main character was wearing a fashion disaster. How is this helpful to make a better play? And then the mention about lesbian couples? I don't know about you but I wonder what kind of mind would think of lesbian couples the minute a woman wears masculine clothes? The group didn't have a male member so they had to make do. What are they supposed to do? Make the person have a sex-change? Make the person open her hijab just so she could portray a real character of a man?



To the commenter after Nazriq, you are so obviously biased. Why do you even bother? You generalized BENL students to being Western. This point of view is baseless and a waste of time.

I don't understand why it is ok for Anisah to say 'What the fuck' and 'No effing way' (which is the shorform of no fucking way) regarding the play but the Japanese commenter couldn't say anything as harsh.



What kind of world are we living in now when people could make up anything and pass this as the a point blank truth? Did Anisah offer any advice? Did Anisah even consider the feelings of people who worked hours to produce this play only to be bashed just because 'she didn't like it'? Her post is so fueled by her own emotions that it is so obvious even from the title! A real review is NEUTRAL. Haven't you learned that in class yet, Nazriq? Neutral, as in not biased and not fueled by one's opinion ONLY. Did you even bother to ask the cast members later on or advise them face to face? Instead you opt for all-out bashing for public humiliation. And public humiliation is nothing new in Anisah's blog.

To all the commenters here, TAKE A GRAIN OF SALT while reading this post. There is a reason why people would comment harshly on it. She wrote the blog post then she has to face the consequences whatever it is. If she has the RIGHT to state her opinion, then anonymous two and six has the RIGHT to state THEIR opinion. If you can't take the heat, then why do it?

yukilili said...

just my opinion...
the main chaos of people condemning your post here is not because of your opinion of how pagan and unislamic the play are, but the way you used your words to express your trauma from watching those plays. i was shocked when i read your post. it was too honest, too frank that leads to the word 'rude' came on my mind.

i was there and me too was shocked with all those sex, boobs whatever things.

but, based on my experience, for drama students the main point of doing the play is to get good marks, and to get good marks, students listen to what lecturer have to say, and if they say none, students accept it as it is OK. (the play was rehearsed in front of their lecturer btw) students always except whatever that comes from their lecturers mouth, as we respect their opinions and their brains too and also because most students including me are not creative or know how to express ideas.
making a play, all we think is to get rid of it as soon as possible, as it is too burdensome and final exam is around the corner.

again, people who watched the plays and read your post would understand what you feel but they might not agree with the way you chose your words. oh yeah, if someone reply a comment asking what is wrong with the way she wrote, please read again and set your brain in neutral mode.bias is not needed here.

p/s btw, the same goes to those wrote comment no. 2. you are rude too though you have your points there which i agree and that person who reply a comment in japanesse, you are far beyond rudeness. calling people stupid and pig is uncivilized. and both of you are anonymous.lame.

oh yeah, saying both Benl students and lecturers twisted makes you sound twisted too.

Anonymous said...

The theme of the second drama is not suicide. For the love of everything that is MERCIFUL, it's about a woman who has a split personality disorder (YES, it was already explained in the play in the scene where the husband is talking to the psychologist). Just thought I'd put that out there, since the production crew is being accused of being ~*~*~anti-Islamic*~*~*

Mdm Azimah said...

MasyaAllah!
Don't worry, I will most certainly look into the syllabus.It's a serious cause of concern. I've already given Anisah advice about choice of words. I am very sensitive to it myself.

kim said...

i think it's anisah's right to comment, and everyone's right here to reply to what she has to say..

but i have to say, think of her as a critic writing a review (and btw, reviews are pretty bashing, no surprise here).. if you want to be in a field such as broadway, acting and such, you'll have to get used to criticism. anisah's personal blog will just be one of it.. you'll get more (good and bad reviews) flooding in. embrace it with good spirits lah, tomorrow will come and there's always another day to prove those critics wrong (or right), right?

and of course your play didn't totally suck. main actors, imo, were good, but i have to say... it could be better. :)

good luck to everyone.

Alyaa said...

I wonder how you put up with this. I wonder why you even do this. Heh.

I didn't go to that play so I can't and won't say anything about that. But Anisah, you should be wise with your words next time around, kays?

Some people might take it personally, you know?

And frankly, Nazriq, I think you shouldn't comment here because you're bound to agree with Anisah lol.

Cheers boys and girls.

Zilah said...

Dear anonymous,
clearly you are inciting a war. You are rallying your mates to personally attack a person-how lame.

Whether Lysistrata is appropriate or not, it's not. End of discussion. No need to defend it--it's paganistic so of course if you want to stage it, have the decency to talk about the 'lesson' from it, unless you never learned how to make things Islamic. As what MDm Azimah said, stand by your ground as a Muslim, bukan main berlakon aje. Has no IRK lecturers taught anything Islamic you can borrow quotes from? at least with that, the audience can benefit from it, instead of watching something immoral and leave feeling sick to the tummy.

as for the second play, what lesson can we derive from that?
Pelik lah

Anonymous said...

Er, did you really expect people to be nice when you write a horrible review accusing 40+ people from two different sections of drama class (who worked hard on the plays) for being anti-Islam? I think these people actually deserve to justify and defend themselves.

anisah shurfa said...

er, i think the fact that comments are enabled means I'm giving everyone a chance to speak their mind and defend themselves.

Anonymous said...

this shouldn't be such a big deal (of course people would deny it)
My point is, everyone has FLAWS in their point of view. Meaning the factor of this whole conflict is that Anisah wrote a post and some people are acting irrationally. People should act MATURE and INTELLIGENT by receiving a comment and defending it in a calm way. People dont need to defend it in a harsh way by taking it personnally. :)

Anonymous said...

Wow!!! what a great comment but I agree with yukilili it is not about the issue so much that people are voicing out but the way you express it what makes people hate it that much... well... it's good for you to be true in ur comment but sometimes just might wanna watch the language that you use so that nobody will be hurt by ur language...

besides it is so funny cause you criticize the actress for the second drama on how fashion victims she is cause as far as i concern if you look back, you are actually her... so convicted for being fashion victims every second and every day... hahahaha... owh... i remember that is why you really wanna criticize her aren't you??? so that she will feel what you used to feel... poor anisah...

OOOPPPSSS!!! before I go, sorry about the language of mine... I'm too honest till I forgot about ur feelings...

wanna know what anisah??... a true muslims did not attack other muslim cause it is almost like you are killing your own brothers and sisters... So look in the mirror and ask your self are you really a true muslim by doing this???... shame on you... think before you write... look into yourself first before you criticize others... I understand that you might wanna defend urself by saying it is just your opinion but to me it is not an opinion it is more to criticizing and what worst is that it hurt others... It is ok if you wanna give an advise to them but do it in a respected way... only respected people deserve to be respected remember??... Do you really want people to loose their respect on you???... you want people to call you BASTARD where ever you go??... do you really want that??... think about it... think about what you have done and take it as a lesson lol!!!...

before I go, why you wanna make enemy if you can have thousands of friends???...

maybe that is all for now...
hahaha... so long looser!!!... once again sorry with my language but I'm willing to do anything if that might help to educate you...

written by,
who concern about ur hurtful language...

Anonymous said...

I am incredibly shocked at the rudeness of this post. Opiniated is one thing. But downright 'kurang ajar' is another thing.

Zilah, that is unfair. You are not rebutting the commenters on their opinion of the play but instead on their personalities and moral values?? Wow, you don't even know these people. And about being anonymous, giving yourself a name apart from anonymous isn't any less cowardly or lame. If you are all about standing on your own opinions, you are doing a poor example. At least give out your email so people can actually contact you and explain their situation. But I guess, you took the easy way out.

If you are discussing whether Lysistrata is appropriate or not because it is paganistic, then you have completely missed the ball. BENL stands for Bachelour of English Literature. ENGLISH LITERATURE. English, the people of Britain, who are pretty much not Muslims. If you are asking whether it is appropriate or not, then the whole course of BENL is inappropriate. Because Shakespeare is a non-muslim. Does this mean that every time a person recites Shakespeare's poetry, he is anti-Islamic? Does this mean that every time a person reads Chaucer, Virginia Woolf etc he becomes anti-Islamic. Wake up! Most of the media in our television are not Muslims! Some of them are Christians, Jews, Buddhists! Does this mean when we watch these television shows, we are being anti-Islam? Are you that narrow-minded?

Plus, correct me if I am wrong but aren't you a Harry Potter fan? Isn't Harry Potter paganistic? It's about witches and not only that, but murder and suicide as well.

So, can I accuse YOU of being anti-Islam? Because you like paganistic literature? From your point of view, IT IS A RESOUNDING YES.

Anonymous said...

We would've responded to this post in a MATURE and INTELLIGENT manner if Anisah herself had been acting in a MATURE and INTELLIGENT manner. People will treat you how you treat them. People do not have the time to play childish games of bantering if it is not offensive. It is obvious that it is offensive. Hopefully, Anisah can respond to all this anger in a MATURE and INTELLIGENT manner which she had failed to portray earlier on.

We did not incite a war. Anisah managed to offend enough number of people to make it into her own warfare. This is all her doing.

pemerhati said...

salaam... kak zimah, kalau kak zimah btul2 nak tlg adik kakak tu, boleh x kak zimah suruh die jgn merayap-rayap dgn bf die setiap mase? sy nmpk slalu je anisah dgn bf die. pagi, petang, malam, berdua je! sy rasa ini x patut. mungkin sy ckp terkluar topik sikit tp sbb isu skrang ni kat komen-komen lain pun pasal islam dan kepentingan peribadi seorg muslim, jd sy pun menyelah masuk. nasihat bolehkan?

klu btul2 die nak ckp pasal kepentingan islam, sy rasa die x patut slalu berdue-due dgn bf die tu! bkn ke 'dating' haram?? bkn ke bila berdue-due ada seorg yg ketiga iaitu syaitan?? dahlah kat kompaun uia! lepas tuh ada hati nak komen org tak islam. tak baik mengutuk org tak islam, ble kite sendiri pun buat dosa memanjang... muhasabahkan diri tu sikit dik dan bertaubatlah. ni kakak bace blog ni pun agak terkejut dgn perangai bdk2 benl tp akak rase adik pun kne berubah jgak. cerminkan diri. tnye diri dah ckp ke jd muslimah sblm mengata org? jgnlah mengata dik, nasihat dahlah.. akak ni dah lama memerhati adik. dik nampak baek tp tu je lah yang sy rasa x puas. klu dah rasa bersedia, kawin je lah. jgnlah buat maksiat pagi rambang lepas tu panggil diri plajar uia!

sy slalu gak dtg ke blog ni tp x perasan ada kak zimah. jd, kak zimah tolong ye? dah pun name pensyarah uia. adik pun plajar uia. sy x faham macam mane ni bleh berlaku...

Amnah said...

Trying not to sound bias (since I am your sister)... I believe that you had expected such verbal bashing - be it in English or Japanese.

I think that anonymous is getting a bit too emotional here. Yes, she (or he, but I think it's a she) has a right to defend herself, but she should be more open to criticism and defend the dramas without being overly dramatic and attacking Anisah on a personal level.

I imagine, if I was in anonymous' shoes, I would fire back the way she has. But the only difference I would make would to not have published my comment without editing it at least 5 times (after several hours of cooling down).

And to Anisah, I don't agree with the way you write: you are rude, conceited, obnoxious - but that doesn't mean I was not entertained.

Anonymous said...

i think, those yg x tengok d play hv no right to say a word. it's not fair to the students.

Anonymous said...

I hope you realize the number of people's feelings you've hurt out of this. You crossed the line, girl. All the best.

Anonymous number-who-know-what said...

anisah, say something! i'm sure you already prepared something before you even posted this post, right?

Oh, yeah, one commentor said that anisah should think before she writes. Judging by the words anisah uses in this post, I can safely say this wicked little girl has definitely put a lot of thought into her writing.

It's exactly how she intended it to be - witty, cruel, and downright controversial.

Aisya said...

Hello, all of you.

Ok, so Anisah didn't exactly write a raving review about your play. But she never attacked anyone involved in the play personally. I don't see why these people involved are getting so defensive. Getting really awful reviews is something expected if you're involved with staging a production. Imagine you're George Lucas, for instance. Some people loved the newer Star Wars episodes. But a lot of people hated them, too. And a lot of people who hated the movies bashed the hell outta the episodes as well as insulted Lucas, calling him a money-minded git who has lost his touch and is just milking the cash cow that is Star Wars. Now, that's what you call personally attacking someone. I've never seen George Lucas throwing a hissy fit about all the hatred directed at him though.

I'm a 3rd year Literature major in UM, and it totally surprises me to see so many literature students from UIA be immature about ONE review written by someone who saw the play. Yes, Anisah should've realised that, generally, Malaysians are sensitive, and usually, wit and sarcasm gets taken literally and in the wrong way. Take, for example, replacing the word 'alcohol' with 'sparkling Ribena'. Oh my God, you guys, that was a JOKE. Of course, some people are just not blessed with a wicked sense of humour to get that. But it's okay.

What's NOT okay, though, are the personal attacks on Anisah. I understand that a lot of people feel an immense amount of hostility towards her (for reasons I totally get, cuz I went to high school too and realise that some people never actually grow out of their high school phase), but please. Anisah said the PLAY was unIslamic, not the people involved in the play. If you wrote Lysistrata, then yes, I understand why you would be offended. But you didn't write the script, did you? To those who believe Anisah called you, as a person, unIslamic, then please, provide for me the exact verbatim quote.

Anisah also did not deny that you've worked hard. I do understand that people involved will feel bitter about this review because you've worked so hard on it... But really. Take a step back and read it subjectively. Look at it from an outsider's point of view, and don't let your emotions get in the way. That's what professionals do. It's what they HAVE to do.

One thing UM lecturers have taught me about studying Western literature is that we cannot accept everything that's given to us by the Ones Who Rule in the World of English Literature and worship what they tell us is great. To anonymous#2, so what if the play is some famous masterpiece written by some famous prolific Greek dude? Doesn't mean its absolutely the best thing everrrr and it doesn't mean anyone who criticises it should be laughed at for going against the norm. In fact, a person who questions the norms and conventional thought should be admired.

I'll share with you what I learnt today in my Literary Criticism class. We read 'To His Coy Mistress' by Andrew Marvell, who is this great metaphysical poet from the Renaissance era, and he is, well, just awesome because he was witty and clever and he was probably really hot... So anyway, 'To His Coy Mistress' is a poem where he praises this girl's beauty, and he uses really clever language in doing so. And he does all this because, basically, he wants to sleep with the girl in the poem. Now, this poem is in the Literature Canon because men dominated the scene at the time, and the cleverness of the poem is something that should be praised, despite the fact that its message is completely sexist and backwards. If Marvell were alive and had written that poem in this day and age, women everywhere would probably be outraged at how men these days still think of women as sex objects. So what am I trying to say? Don't be silly and accept everything just cuz other people tell you it's good. Truly intelligent people are those who can question authority and strive to make a positive change.

Somewhere in cyberspace, someone involved in the play bashed Anisah's review and wrote something somewhere along the lines of this:

"The objective of the play IS to get the audience to feel disgust..."

Then why are you so angry that Anisah feels disgust? I say you should feel happy. That makes your production a success, don't you think? ;)

And staging the play just to please the lecturer isn't really an admirable thing to do, to be frank. Honestly, if you're staging a play just to get an A and not care about the message you're sending across to those watching, then that's just not very good. I thought UIA students are supposed to do more than that? If not, then I'm deeply disappointed to find out that you lot are becoming just as kiasu as a lot of students from other colleges and universities who are not blessed to have gotten a spot in a university that should be proud to say that they are a 'Garden of Knowledge and Virtue'. Emphasis on 'Virtue'

If you stage a crappy play (and I'm not saying you did, because I'm in no place to say that since I didn't watch it), the weakest argument you could give to defend it would be, 'oh but it's supposed to be a masterpiece and so you must bow down and praise it!' Have you ever watched movies based on Shakespeares dramas? Take, for example, the various different versions of Hamlet. Notice the many differences there are in each version? That's because the directors have taken the scripts into their hands and interpreted it their way. Which is a totally okay thing to do. So to the commentor who wrote that you couldn't have changed the script, I can safely say to you that, yes, you actually can change the script.

To those of you who keep going on about how Anisah has offended 40+ people, stop being so dramatic. What makes you think the review is biased in the first place? Obviously you have OTHER personal issues with Anisah, and assume that anything Anisah writes that involves you in any way is biased.

Oh yeah, Anisah. You maybe kinda have dug a grave for yourself by using language that's a bit too sarcastic for the simpler mind, but I know your intentions are good. See, I actually can understand that a message you're trying to put across is that UnIslamic plays shouldn't be staged if there's no positive lesson to be learned from them. Those of you who argue that the audience should be mature enough to extract messages without having the messages be shoved in their faces, you should understand, too, that you need to effectively prompt the audience to think. When a whole bunch of people in the audience leave the play just feeling disgusted at the crappiness of the play, then you should assume that it was just bad directing.

;)

anisah shurfa said...

First of all, I sincerely apologise to the crew members for managing to piss them all off simultaneously by writing my review. As my sisters say, what I wrote was harsh, rude, conceited and arrogant. I know you must have put a lot of hard work and effort, and obviously it hurts to read something on the Internet that lambasted your weeks of hard work into smithereens of minute proportions.

But then again, harsh as my review was, deal with it. Being criticised is a part of life, women. Just check out all the movie reviews out there -- a majority of them are insulting to the core. And, unlike me, they freely mention the names of the actors. By right, I could have easily said your names and further humiliated you. I didn't, because I actually do respect you guys. Notice that not one of my criticism regarding the play is directed personally towards any of the actors? That's how objective I'm being.

To my haters, who are also obviously the crew, I didn't write this post because I'm an attention-seeking-whore whose life revolves around Me and My Blog. Do you realise how stupid you sound? If that were true, I'd be updating every day, not once a month, innit?

Nor did I write it because I've a personal grudge against you or I'm biased. If that were true, I'd be insulting the people involved in it personally.

I wrote this because I thought it was about time someone took a stand against such Westernised nonsense that is going on around here, our Islamic university.

As for my sarcasm and jokes littered in the post that may border on being offensive and rude... well, who wants to read a boring, endless rant? I took time to make sure people would be entertained when they read this ;-)

Obviously, my post has made you blind with rage to the point that you can't see what I'm trying to say. So I'll put it in simpler, laymen terms. I didn't like the second drama because of the message it was giving to the audience. Mainly, suicide.

In my honest opinion, it wasn't right of you to depict two suicide scenes so graphically on stage in an Islamic university, in front of an Islamic audience comprising of parents, lecturers, peers and children. But if you insist on doing it, why not insert an Islamic value there as well, stating that suicide is a sin? Otherwise, there is no point to it. And do not justify the suicide by saying the characters were kafir or it's due to a mental disability.... Islam does not justify suicide.

Hadith - Bukhari 2:445, Narrated Thabit bin Ad-Dahhak

The Prophet said, "Whoever intentionally swears falsely by a religion other than Islam, then he is what he has said, (e.g. if he says, 'If such thing is not true then I am a Jew,' he is really a Jew). And whoever commits suicide with piece of iron will be punished with the same piece of iron in the Hell Fire." Narrated Jundab the Prophet said, "A man was inflicted with wounds and he committed suicide, and so Allah said: My slave has caused death on himself hurriedly, so I forbid Paradise for him."

Hadith - Bukhari 7:670, Narrated Abu Huraira

The Prophet said, "Whoever purposely throws himself from a mountain and kills himself, will be in the (Hell) Fire falling down into it and abiding therein perpetually forever; and whoever drinks poison and kills himself with it, he will be carrying his poison in his hand and drinking it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever; and whoever kills himself with an iron weapon, will be carrying that weapon in his hand and stabbing his abdomen with it in the (Hell) Fire wherein he will abide eternally forever."

You say you staged your drama to elicit shock and disgust within the audience. Well, congratulations! You succeeded in shocking and disgusting me so much that I wrote this post! So why are you so unhappy?

I'd also like to add that any drama can instil emotions within an audience, because, honestly, everyone has emotions! But shocking and disgusting people without carrying a message across? Even a simple 'by the way, suicide is bad!' would have been greatly appreciated.

So, is it clear now why I think the second drama was God-awful and unislamic?

anisah shurfa said...

Oh, and by the way, Pemerhati you are a condescending, idiot, misunderstood, wannabe stalker that I'd rather do without. Back off.

Anonymous said...

i don't mean to sound rude anisah but if you REALLY watched the play, the girl WASN'T commiting suicide. she is sick and she doesn't know that side of her. she didn't intend to COMMIT SUICIDE.
you should REALLY understand the play before JUDGING. and don't be rude. the words you use are VERY offensive and you give ppl who doesn't watch the plays A VERY BIASED OPINION.
please consider other ppl's feelings and the hardwork they put in. you're making as if the plays are trash. that's very offensive of you.

Anonymous said...

girl, all this while i see you as someone really nice since i don't really know you. heck, i don't even know you at all but reading this, it just reflects your whole personality.
hahaha. you go girl. you managed to get the whole batch to hate you ;)

What is up with BENL students? said...

Oh man. Looks like the 2 anonymous BENL students who wrote after anisah's last comment still don't get it and manage to make themselves sound stupid. My respect for BENL students will really go down the drain if the WHOLE BATCH are a bunch of immature twits who can't take it when an audience member who watches their play don't like their production.

BOO HOO. Grow the heck up.

Anonymous said...

Anisah, you should make your last comment a blog post.

Anyone who continues to say stupid things after this is just an immature overemotional piece of...

:D

Anonymous said...

i agree with one of the anonymous commenters.
yes if you say that the plays are unislamic, then the WHOLE benl course should not even exist at all.
to advice one is to reflect yourself. using curses and words that are harsh while trying to preach to ppl to be islamic is just...WEIRD. practice what you preach. i think this is too much and i no longer think that your post is criticizing. i rather call it bashing. even though you didn't bash any of the actors, you bashed their work which is horrible. what would you feel if you're in their shoes. you give your all into something and someone else suddenly says it should be thrown into a valley of poo. what would you feel?
if you really are islamic yourself, please then accept the criticisms. YOU crossed the borderline. and do not expect your feelings to be the same with others. ppl said it was fun to watch both plays which contradicts with your post.
please reread your post and put yourself into the shoes of the ppl you criticized. then maybe you will know how they feel :}

anisah shurfa said...

She was attempting to commit suicide. whether she was sick or not, it is still a SIN. And not one of you on stage bothered to point it out. Shame on you for wasting such an opportunity.

And further shame on you for defending your play under the cloaks of anonymity. If you're so proud of your production, why not state your name?

You're asking me to consider other people's feelings. I did and I have, hence the apology for hurting people's feelings! But as I mentioned before, always be prepared for harsh criticism; from your peers, your lecturers, your bosses, etc. Because that is what life is.

Yes, I know hard work was put into the production. Credits to the crew. But that still doesn't make the play redeemable. Example; I'm sure Salman Rushdie put hard work into writing The Satanic Verses, but does that mean we should be more gentle in criticising it?

Last but not least; if I make it sound like I thought the play was trash, isn't that my personal opinion?

Anonymous said...

Yes, poster above me. Yes, we know you FEEL offended because you worked hard. But hard work doesn't necessarily produce great work.

And I don't agree with that opinion about BEN not existing if everything in it is unIslamic. Because learning literature is actually learning how to question and criticise and think in a broader way. Studying literature in UIA should teach u to look at lit from an Islamic perspective. The plays failed to do that.

sarah iqbal said...

i would prefer if all those yg tak puas hati with dis post, at least, have the guts to use ur own name instead of "anonymous". what are you trying to hide yeah by using anonymous? sheeesh.

btw, blog anisah, suke hati dier lah nak tulis ape pun. kalau tak puas hati, jgnlah bace. =)

Anonymous said...

The woman. Wasn't. Committing. Suicide.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissociative_identity_disorder

Anonymous said...

Anisah. Your efforts in an apology is so ridiculous, it is incredulous. You hated the second drama because it is about suicide? Were you too busy canoodling with your boyfriend to not notice what it is actually about?

The whole drama is NOT about suicide. If you think it is, then you had obviously misinterpreted the play. It is understandable as you admittedly say that you are not a BENL student hence you posibbly could not evaluate a play correctly.

So, I will repeat this again, as countless have had, that the play revolves around a character with a split personality. Dissociative disorder meaning a person can have multiples of personality. Please REPEAT this in your head a couple of times so that you will remember this as you seemed to be so bent on this suicide theory of yours. The character who was 'cutting' her wrist was NOT in the verge of committing suicide. She was having a violent and self-destructive episode from her illness. The scenes of her with fake blood on her wrists are to show evidence of her multiple personalities.

IS THAT SO HARD FOR YOU TO GRASP?

I am guessing you do not have the capacity to actually think this through but our play did not promote suicide. Dissociative disorders are not diseases that you can catch or even habits you can practice. You actually HAVE to have a mental disorder in order to commit all the violent acts depicted in the play. Those 'violent' scenes are only there to show the different side of her and not just pointless gore.

Hate is a strong word. I think you are more leaning to 'ignorant'. We do not condone suicide. If we did, we would have one character dead from committing suicide and all the other characters agreeing to the idea of suicide.

Excuse me, but if you cannot interpret a simple play correctly, why are you so obsessively obnoxious about it? It's so pathetic. You are so pathetic.

Even more pathetic that you hated the second drama but also happily bashed the first one as well. You are just this grumpy bitchy person who has a lot of anger to unload. Seek immediate help.

Anonymous said...

^Look who's talking! Who's the one grumpy angry bitchy one?

Heehee... In my opinion, the review isn;t an angry one la! It's a witty sarcastic one!

Some people ah... can never understand wit.

UNISLAMIC ANISAH ADVISES OTHER PPL ABT ISLAM said...

oh wow. i had THE BEST LAUGH out of my life from Pemerhati's comment!

AND I HAD EVEN MORE LAUGH AFTER READING YOURS!


dear dear anisah, pemerhati is advising you about being a good muslim and she/he is absolutely RIGHT. YOU said kenapa orang tak boleh accept criticism WHEN YOU YOURSELF COULDN'T! HAHAHAHA. eeiii gediknya. if i were u, i'd be so malu. macam BAPAK OBVIOUS yang you sendiri adalah seorang hipokrit.

mmg dlm islam tak bagi berdua-duaan org yg bkn muhrim. betul lah. apa yg you ckp pasal benl plays pun ada betul jgk. tak islamic. tapi ko pun tak islamic. yg aku tak faham kenapa ko sendiri yang KONON nak menegak AGAMA ISLAM dlm hal org laen tetapi bile or tegur sikit pasal kesalahan diri TAKNAK DGR. tapi sbb tak defend diri tu sbb aku rasa mmg ko BUAT PUN DATING DGN BF KAN? HAHAHA. lawak ah ko ni anisah. lawak gile.

dah dah, nak bagi hadis, ada lagi berlambak hadis pasal man and woman and prohibitions. tapi tu tak dgr. ko ni apa? muslim moden? buat satu tak buat lagi satu. haish.. apa nak jadi dgn dunia.

kalau budak uia pun camni, budak kat luar camna lagi?

Nyehehe said...

I think the ones who are leaving bitchy comments actually love the review. And the drama that is ensued from it. HAH!

One person posted the review in a facebook note and wrote:

'Guys look, an unwanted review!'

If it's unwanted, then why are you promoting it to everyone?

*duh moment*

african goddess said...

ya allah.

can some people relax...?

to begin, assalamu'alaikum to all.
I AM A BENL STUDENT TOO.
and i did that very same assignment last semester. my friends did that assignment too.

sometimes we make mistakes.
so anisah was commenting.
is this not HER blog?
the idea of having a blog is to have the freedom to say whatever she want, bukan ke?

i mean, if you don't like it, don't read it.

couldn't you guys just take her criticism as a constructive one? i thought BEN students are supposed to be more open to suggestions and comments.

take it for yourself, to improve in the future. tak boleh ke?

i punya assignment pun kena criticize jugak.
so am i supposed to blow my top off and go crazy?

anisah shurfa said...

Yes, it is hard to grasp.

Because you failed to convey the message during the play that it wasn't a suicide scene. Instead, you had to explain elaborately on my blog.

Which means the audience went away with a completely different message then the one you intended. Besides, a play is open for interpretation, innit?

Anonymous said...

WOI, ORANG BONGOK YANG AGREE DENGAN PEMERHATI TU.

Why are you being such an asshole? Salah ke yang Anisah is saying that the play is unislamic and menegakkan kabaikan? Because what she's saying is true!

Pemerhati is a creep because she's attacking Anisah on a personal level. Macamlah pemerhati tu tak buat dosa. Everyone commits sins.

Anisah has written negatively about the PLAY, idiot. Not the people in it. Kenapalah kamu tak faham?

anisah shurfa said...

To the people who are commenting on my "dating activities":

You are committing the fallacy of "Look Who's Talking". Look it up.

You see, I could be the most unIslamic person on earth, but that doesn't mean my argument on the play is void.

Besides, I assure everyone who is worried about my level of Islamic-ness: I am striving to improve myself everyday :)

Forensic Linguist to-be said...

Don't worry Anisah, being a linguist grad, I can kindda put my money in this when I say that it's the SAME circle of girls who are writing to you, that has culminated into 51 comments (actually, only about 10 are probably written by diff people). This Pemerhati is also a false identity--kindda obvious with the writing. Let me double check with my linguist lecturer on that. We're decoding things.. we're obsessed.

You're above this high school drama aren't you? These girls are hurt that you attacked their hardwork, and your review, which never even touched on how darn hard they worked, is simply lost on their anger, and most probably history they have had with you. Don't worry, we know who these circle of girls are. Soon, they will eat each other up too with their brand of wit and fantastic language. But that's fate's work. Sigh. I think I love decoding this so much, I'm a fan of Ben students!

Forensic Linguist to-be said...

Oh my god, is anyone awake? Am I too late?

haris said...

masalah la korang ni.(pihak yg melawan je eh)
klau korang nak cari gaduh or memang sakit hati ngan si Anisah ni, tak perlu la guna alasan untuk nak kenekan guna post ni.. saja je.. saya sbagai budak sekolah tgk ni cam budak2 skolah jugak.. korang belum matang lagi eh? haha.. macam kanak2 ribena la. bak kata Anisah "sparkling Ribena". haha! (eh aku baru perasan aku sorang ckp bahasa melayu. hahaha)

non-UIA said...

LOL. People, chill la...

Anisah was being rude (from the way she wrote the blog entry) so it is natural for you guys to get pissed-off like hell.

Even if the plays were misinterpreted (by Anisah), you can't blame her 100%. I wasn't there that night (yes, shame on me for still wanting to leave a comment) but I'd like to point out that THE AUDIENCE, they DON'T KNOW ANYTHING about the plays.

If you were part of the production crew, of course you knew what your play was all about.

You can defend the theme of your play as much as you like, but if the audience dislike / failed to understand your play, maybe it was (partly) your fault. Maybe your play was weak. (As in, script, performance, concept etc)

Commenters, please stop defending/bashing Anisah. Tak ke mana pun. Baik comment pasal apa korang leh improve dari plays tu.

anisah shurfa said...

No, you're not too late ;-) I have a feeling this drama won't be dying out any time soon, judging by the velocity of the defensive comments

Adilah said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Kwon Yuri said...

me: a BENL student, and was involved in one of the plays.

comments: i WON'T say anything.

just a reminder: (to ANYONE)

You'll be responsible for everything you are doing.

Allah says:
"Every soul draws the meed of its acts on none but itself: no bearer of burdens can bear the burden of another.

Your goal in the end is towards Allah: He will tell you the truth of the things wherein you disputed"

(Al-An'am,6,164)

ALLAH IS WATCHING EVERY SINGLE THING U'RE DOING.

HE KNOWS BEST.

do bear in mind, people.

salam~

Adilah said...

I had to delete my other comment since it was rather vague. Anyway...

I should teach them choral speaking?? Mwahahah that is an amusing thought. Just because I entered a choral speaking competition, yeah? thanks anyway for featuring my name in your ever-so-popular blog. Keh keh.

As for your reviews, I refuse to comment on them because I haven't seen the dramas. It isn't fair to comment when you have no idea what actually happened, right? That's where critical thinking comes into use. I'm being fair. Heheh.

Anisah Anisah... The amount of haters you've managed to amass on your own is amazing. No doubt they cannot fathom the deeper meaning of your blog(or that they have a vendetta against you, but I would rather not assume). Sure, the words you choose may reflect on you being rude, obnoxious (plus whatever else your sisters have tagged you with) and it hurts when your brainchild is criticised no matter how gentle the critic may be, but it is also just plain rude when you attack the person instead of arguing about what is written. Once again, critical thinking helps here.

OK, clearly most of the anonymous people who have bashed you in English or Japanese (daymn. can i learn to curse from who-used-it? :P)were being unfair and biased. evidently, you have something against Anisah. criticise what she has said, not who she is. anyone can tell you that.

You know what, Anisah? Just live your life as it suits you. Don't let the immmature, biased critics define how you should live your life. They're not the ones who're gonna bail you out of hell. Heheh.

Anywayz, your review has been very entertaining for me, even though I was shocked with the language used. Careful there. I may be on your side, but I will say something when you cross the line. Consider yourself warned (hehe threatening much?.

Good luck with life and miss you lots!

Anonymous said...

i have seen a lot of comments regarding this post;some of them agreed and some of them were not. basically, as one of the so-called crew that night, i do feel uneasy by the way she commented on both plays. the words used were harsh and i can say they were rude.but since this is her blog, so i take it positively on anything that i feel positive to be reflected in my life from now on.
just so u know anisah, eventhough this site gives u an infinity of freedom to say anything, but please, as a friend,bear in mind that you should have a right choice of words when commenting or expressing something. you did have some reasonable reasons to criticize the plays,but it will be more acceptable if you did that carefully. Rasulullah s.a.w himself advised the people during his time,be it Muslims or non- Muslms, with what we call,berhikmah.he didnt do that rudely and hurt others.so y didnt you think before you write? i clearly know your intention , which was to make us realize that the way we presented the plays was unIslamic and we should be careful with the scripts. but to emotionally bashing ppl, i think that was improper. and again, if only you criticized the plays with rationality and hikmah, ppl can still accept regardless how hurtful the truth was.yeah we know,truth can be hurtful,but can you decrease the pain a little by using the proper way? i am sure u can.btw,this comment is written with a clear state of mind and not infused with any negative emotions,so i hope i wont insult you with my comment.thank you for criticizing , at least we can identify the flaws and what should and should not to do after this. and for the anti-Islamic, at least you should have proofs,cuz if you say that without knowing the real truth then it will be too bad,just like fitnah. you didnt know the real intention of the actors/actresses when mentioning the Zeus line.were they really mean it or take it as a mere word? Only ALLAH knows indeed.so, whatever it is, it will be between ALLAH and the person him/herself. no need to say if you don't know.
well, u and i, all of us are striving to improve ourselves, so y dont each of us give a chance to forgive and forget? u have done ur role as a Muslim by making the ppl concerned realized that some things were un-okay, and some of the ppl concerned accepted AND,suggesting that right and proper and 'himahly' ways should be implemented so that no more ppl will get hurt when reading what u've posted.so, what do you think?=)

Marhaen said...

Salam...the reason why UIA offered BENL programme is because of the noble idea of islamicising the "human sciences/knowledges". It should be noted that none of the human produced knowledege can withstand without tying up it to the revelation of Allah s.w.t.
Therefore, the study of poetry/drama/prose and whatever that the student study should and must be viewed from Islamic perspective as well. So it is a task for BENL student in UIA to continue this noble idea. If the students can perform this task then it will be a good thing for UIA BENL programme for it is different from other BENL/LIT programme in other universities. Yes, not all thing from the West is bad but if it so crystal clear that it is bad and against Islam why should we follow it. Instead this is the avenue for us to criticize it. As for the comment that says all BENL course are UnIslamic you are not looking at this critically. It is your duty to point that it is UNISLAMIC. You can't just follow the flow and if you point it out i think that your lecturer will appreciate it. Please remember your first identity before you do sumthing...whether you are a Muslim or a BENL student first. If you take that your first identity as BENL student than you are going to defend anything eventough it is wrong. But when u take Muslim as your first identity then all the UNISLAMIC thing won't be surfaced whether in your play, poem, writing and etc. Pls dont blame the whole BENL course but blame yourself for not understanding the noble aspiration behind the introduction of this programme long before you were born. Please stop being ignorant for you can't grow up and see the "hikmah" behind things.

Anonymous said...

I dont care about defending anyone here or to defend the plays or what-so-ever because it doesnt bother me at all, just that when I read this blog it truly shows anisah's true side and actually before this I was wondering why people hates u and NOW I really UNDERSTAND why U DONT HAVE ANY FRIENDS.. poor u Anisah..
U keep mentioning about improving urself but I just don't see it.. "Cakap tak serupa bikin" rite?
Not just that, since u want to tell everyone about what u truly feels, weel, Im gonna tell u what everyone feels about u.. Yup, u.
Actually rite now the number of people who hates u increases each day and each time u blink ur eyes. U r making a lot of enemies n I dont think that I should believe what u say is true, n yeah, it is not easy to make a lot of people to hate a person just like that, but u did Anisah, u did..
Well done! Bravo! If u really are a good muslimah & u always stick to hadiths that u has provided here, I think everyone would be okay with what u r tring to say, but, what I see is that u "JUST ENTERTAINING" ppl with those harsh words.
N u know what, yup, u hv entertain a lot of ppl including me BUT the problem is that "NOBODY LAUGH". Maybe this is the kind of life that u want. So go ahead, write anything u want, other people's feeling doesn't matter rite?
Just like what u said that u r trying to improve, yup, u do improve in a negative way. Do u know that "what goes around,comes back around", maybe u don't from the way u r living your life, let me tell u something, U always complain or critisizing about oth people (n a lot more of oth stuffs), dont u notice that people do complain a lot about u. Well, thats what u asked for.
Congratulations n well done for destroying ur own reputation (to those who thinks that Anisah is not a bad person, I was one of them before). U hv done it very well. If u ever want to blame anyone because ur life is just SO MISERABLE, well, blame urself.
U r messing with ppl who will fight back and stand for themselves! U cannot run from this messes that u hv just created anisah, just be careful, u have gained a lot of attentions rite now, thats what u want rite.. Dont feel weird if u feel that ppl r watching u in disgust and hatred. U get what u pay for. Be prepared for any consequences, hatred will haunt u anywhere u go.

Yours sincerely,
ur concerned reader

Anonymous said...

Whateva to the poster above me. Just anotha overemotional weed who's attacking on a personal level, showing your own stupidity. Haven't you read the more intelligent comments yet? If ya, then diam je lah!

Anonymous said...

OMG u totally dead anisah..shame on u..u dont even know the play is a masterpiece yet u still can talk proudly about your opinion about the play..that so not cool..u just want attention by your comment..why dont you study more about the play in the world than you can criticize other..hahaha..your comment really show you are not that genius beb.. ;)

peace said...

to 'ur concerned reader',

dude, there you go again, showing emo. chill out man. be intelligent. what for you believe in fitnah? before you spread your hatred towards anisah, be brave n tell us who u are pastu remember, before believing in fitnah, find out how fitnah started.
ok, lets move on and talk about how to improve things. going in circle n circle with how many enemies anisah made makes me hungry. anybody laughing?

Forensic Linguist to-be said...

btw, to claim that there are so many haters, i take critical discourse analysis at UM and can say that this 'claim' is not to be taken seriously because it comes from a biased person--probably the same group of people again. duh. i stand by what i said, these 'haters' are the same people. going in circle2 to spread fitnah. I'm no religious person but i smell foul play when i see one.

Anonymous said...

Wow Anisah, U can truly make a lot of people hates everything about u.. Suites u right I guess. By the way, padan muka ko! Haha.. In your face! Majority wins (Lebih byk org yg x setuju dgn ko)U r doomed!!!

American Idol fanatic said...

Do you know what all this reminds me of? American Idol. Everybody loves Simon Cowell until he criticises you. But we all know that what Simon says is just so true.

And he can't even sing to save his life.

anisah shurfa said...

well, since all my haters go under the same name, which is "anonymous", I agree with Forensic-Linguist-To-Be that they must all come from a small number of people who have nothing better to do than keep bashing me and my blog, so consumed are they with their emotions.

If you really hate me and this post, then why are you wasting your time reading it and commenting again, and again, while pretending to be different people?

Because that? Is just SAD.

You are BENL students. You are supposed to put emotions aside when analysing reviews. Clearly, you did not. And to those who complain that my review is too harsh and rude, and that I should have been more gentle; here's what I have to say to you:

You don't and shouldn't expect to get that in life.

Anonymous said...

Ehmagawd.. Kesian nya u Anisah, I lebih kesian kat u dr budak2 play tu.. U kutuk play tu sama lah dgn u kutuk diorang, n u nak kutuk diorang macam mana pun macamlah orang kat sini semua kenal diorang, tp u.. kesiannya u.. Diorang semua kenal u n kalau u nk kutuk diorang mcm mana pun tak dapat nak tanding kalau diorang semua yang berpuluh-puluh tu kutuk u balik. Tapi at least u jadi popular kan?

Don't Go Into the Valley of Poo! said...

Go Anisah!

To the immature emotional ones leaving poop behind in the comments page... Maybe you should try reading the review again. It's hilarious! At first read, the review does sound harsh, but after the second read, it's so damn funny, yo! Seriously man! Lighten up, kids.

anisah shurfa said...

Btw, you guys, you don't have to feel sorry for me, K? I'm having the time of my life, reading these comments! LOL!

A Word of Caution: said...

BENL STUDENTS, BE WARNED:

THE MORE YOU POST IDIOTIC EMOTIONALLY FUELLED COMMENTS, THE MORE IDIOTIC YOU ARE MAKING YOURSELVES LOOK.

Amnah said...

To those commenting with infused hatred: if yes, Anisah is such a rude, mean, inconsiderate person, then why do you yourself have to go to such low levels as to be just as rude, mean and inconsiderate to her? What, cos she deserves it?

GROW UP. I'm so disappointed in all of you 'brothers' and 'sisters' of UIA... of Islam.

Outsider said...

Assalamualaikum.

Anisah, don't you know that hurting people's feeling is sinful?
and once you do it, you HAVE to beg EACH one of them for forgiveness?
or else ALLAH will no longer shower His mercy on you.
do think about it.
cause your precious life might end at anytime.
and yea, you spelled this wrongly: 'Astarghfillahalazim!', which is supposed to be 'Astagfirullahal'azim'.
be careful. you've changed the meaning too.
and this should have not be produced by a UIA student who is seemed to like 'emphasizing' the islamic value.

A Word of Caution: said...

BENL students calling yourselves 'Outsider' and posting crappy comments in the hopes of other real outsiders not thinking lowly of BENL students?

Epic fail.

Outsider said...

to A Word of Caution,
it is you who failed.
im not a BENL student.

A Word of Caution: said...

Then you are probably still in their circle of friends...

But i wasnt just talking about you..

anisah shurfa said...

So why not prove that by revealing your true identity, "Outsider"? Otherwise we can only take that at face-value.

Amnah said...

Yeah, a true outsider would leave their own name. Outsider? Bagi la nama creative skit kalau nak orang percaya yg u ni betul2 'outsider'.

Some people just gotta learn the art of subtleties.

hazman said...

LOL. u guys r funny. everybody's talking and nobody's listening..

tsk tsk tsk..

african goddess said...

to all BENL students who plan to comment after this comment, please refrain from doing so cuz you're not only embarrassing yourself, you're also making me feel embarrassed of my own course, which is something i have NEVER felt before this despite our weaknesses and discrepancies.

Shame on you for making BENL look bad (or maybe i should say worse since people already think negatively of our course).

Seriously, just shut up.

janedoe said...

Assalamualaikum.
I don't think commenting/bashing/mocking anisah using 'anonymous' is a brave act. You shower her with bad words bravely, but coward in revealing who you really are. And cursing in Japanese? Saitei da yo! You waste your great knowledge in Japanese bashing on people. Shame on you.

I have no right to comment on the plays, but I find it disturbing for anonymous to comment on Anisah's personal life, or Anisah herself, when we are actually discussing/talking about the plays. I cant help but see it as you hating Anisah, not her writing, and you are not actually defending the plays, but rather criticising Anisah sbb diri dia. Dengki? Benci? Tolak tepi ye lain kali.

And please fellow budak benl, jangan cepat melatah. Baru sikit dah nak carut2 kat orang. Entah ape2 la. Be more open ok? Its not like she is revealing the crews one by one and you'll be humiliated throughout your years in UIA. And, did you guys really expect good feedbacks only?

And as always, Anisah's posts are very hard for 'some people' to comprehend or rather too straightforward not in a good way, but being optimistic will help you feel better, in a lot more ways.

Takde niat nak back up sape2. Saling menegur la sesame kite. Beradab la sikit ye :)
Assalamualaikum.

arina said...

salam~hello to anisah and semua p'kritik yg teramat honest sesetengahnye..XD,,anisah,sy x fikir yg all oy ur words tu x kejam,mmg straight to the point lah kate org...kalo yg buat tu,mmg terase la,,XD,,but then,i do agree with sarah iqbal,as this is anisah's blog,so kalo u all x suke ape yg anisah tulis,knape nk menyusahkan diri pegy membazir duet,online untuk open dye pny blog?wlpn nie nmpk mcm bias sbb i d sblh pihak anisah,there's a reason for it.i am a benl studnt too,n nmpknye ramai yg xpuas hati kat cnie pon,budak ben kan?kenape kite nk sokong benda yg x betul,tu dah kire mcm menegakkan benang yg basah and btw,anisah do critics the play,bukannye the actors,,owh people,be professional lah,,benl kan ade blaja oral comm n cct,xkan lah x leh jadi pro,,be open in accepting critics kayh,,its for your own good jugak as nie bru life kat universiti,belum pg kerja lg,kalo tyme pg kerja,u kna kritik dgn u pnye bos,u pg bash ur bos jgak la eh?and untuk yg x puas hati ngan anisah jugak nie,tolong la BROTHER OR SISTERS,post nie adalah pasal play!bukan pasal ader boyfriend atau x, u all nie,kalo nk kritik or ambush org pon,bia lah kna pade tempatnyer,and kalo u ambush dye pasal benda laen sedangkan dye kritik pasal bnda laen,its shows that u are totally a big loser babes!childish pon ade kot,,hehehehe,,,duishhh!sape yg terase mmg x tido malam la agaknye,,XD,,walaupun anisah pg dating, yg awak sibuk nk memerhati tu knape?awk tu xder boyfrn ker?biasenye yg ckp lebih,die buat lg lebih pd org yg dye kutuk tu, and kalo u xde boyfren skrg,ingt,jgn kutuk org lebih2,benda tu akan datang balik kat awak,bnda nie bkn anggapan yea,kerana jika anda memikirkan kata2 ini dengan hati yg waras lg tenang,anda akan sedar yg kata2 ini ada logiknya...chewahhh,,hehe,,

besides,honestly to be a benl student,sometimes x rase bangga pon kerana ramai org ckp budak benl nie perasan bagus,,n i do feel that mmg betul ape org ckp pasal budak ben..x semua yg teruk,tp yg teruk tu lah akn merosakkan name semua org,adakah anda,wahai budak benl,bangga dengan mencarut di hadapan khayalak ramai?dengan menyebut ur private thing sdr, di hdpn kawan lelaki anda,dah la kuat,nk bgtau sume org yg lalu lalang kat dpn area bank tu kot agaknyer,,so people,wlpn ape anisah ckp tu teramat pedas,lu fikirla sendiri and kalo u ckp anisah bash people thet she even dont know, u tu dah cukup knal anisah ker untuk ambush dye di blog?cakap anisah pndi,korang pon sbnrnye tanpa korang sedari,korANG pon turut ambush org jugak nieh...XD,,

be cool babes!

benl student

Anonymous said...

you say the commenters are committing the fallacy of look who's talking. you guys are committing the fallacy of stereotyping. do you know each and every one of benl students to say that "benl students" love western things? just because some of them are, doesnt mean the rest of them are too.

you say that Anisah is commenting on the play, not the people in it. excuse me, did she not comment on the fashion sense of the lead actress? what is that? what she wore was just a costume for the play, and it does not reflect her fashion sense. i see you wear outfits like that sometimes.

to Zilah. you ask what lesson can be derived from the second play + "peliklah". did you actually see it? or you just take anisah's word for it? you say that they are following their lecturers blindly. aren't you doing the same thing? lecturers at least have credibility. is anisah credible enough to comment/'review' the plays? it seems that you people who believes anisah without actually seeing the play are the ones who will eat poop if she told you to.
does she know what Lysistrata is all about?
the disease portrayed by the woman in the second play is a type of psychological disorder. psychology students learn it. isn't that kinda the same?
there are actually a few lessons to be derived from the 2nd play if you really paid attention anisah.
1.we should not jump to conclusions and bersangka buruk without actually knowing the real truth (as seen in the lines of the "voice of reason", as you call it, when the "overdramatic queen" thinks badly of "femme fatale" and Edward.
2. watch your language. this was crystal clear. the voice of reason tells the overdramatic queen to use use euphemism to describe the shrek lady. obviously you didnt take any lesson from this.
& byk lagi.

those who did not watch the plays, you have no right to say anything about it because you cannot vouch for the truth of anisah words. she might just be exaggerating. no family laft the hall. fyi, the families that came were the actors'/actresses'. they came to WATCH their children in the play. they knew what was coming.

since when everyone has total freedom of speech? yes it's her blog. does that mean she can say whatever she wants, even if it's not entirely true? is it okay to spread lies and slander now?
i do not see the constructive criticism in this post. maybe just a little.
if you said that the props were moved too slow, or the backstage was noisy, that is acceptable coz it's true. this was what the other member of the audience said.

why is it ok for anisah to swear but not the commenters who are involved with the play? where;s the justice in that?

enlighten me people.
this is actually amusing.

Daus said...

for goodness! she's not spreading lies or anything, she's just giving something from her point of view. its doesnt have to be right or wrong, just from a POINT OF VIEW.
People these days are just over dramatic. they probably just love the drama.. oh lupa, nmpak sgt korang ada personal issue ngan Anisah ni. damn immature! hahaha..

Rye said...

To Amnah, there's a lot of other things happen here n u are only looking at how outsider is not creative about his/her name? Do u call yourself "creative"? So not.

To "A word of caution", u said about "crappy comments", U urself are posting crappy comments.

To Daus, r u really sure that "she's not spreading lies or anything"? besides it is "just from a POINT OF VIEW", u knoe it n u believe every single thing that she said? Then u r the one who is "damn immature".

To african goddess, even looking at ur names makes me feel embarassed, shame on you too, u asked people to "shut up", u urself should do that.

To Amnah, u urself are "commenting with infused hatred" just like what u say "I'm so disappointed in all of you 'brothers' and 'sisters' of UIA... of Islam." Well u urself should "GROW UP", just because of this issue "you yourself have to go to such low level".

To janedoe: u said "I don't think commenting/bashing/mocking anisah using 'anonymous' is a brave act". Dont u see that she is doing all that too: commenting/bashing/mocking. She gets what she deserve rite? If she cannot handle this situation, thats y she post this blog in the first place.I dont think ppl using 'anynomous' is coward, if they do, they dont have the guts to write here. A said "I cant help but see it as you hating Anisah, not her writing, and you are not actually defending the plays, but rather criticising Anisah sbb diri dia" u r wrong here. When she wrote those stuffs, it shows how she thinks, thats why people not only hate her writing but hate her as well. She should know this n just accept it because this is what she wants, if not ppl will not say those stuffs to her without any reason rite? N u know what, obviosly from her writing, she's the one who is "Dengki? Benci?", so u should also tell her "Tolak tepi ye lain kali". N u said " Anisah's posts are very hard for 'some people' to comprehend or rather too straightforward not in a good way, but being optimistic will help you feel better, in a lot more ways", u urself admit that it is not in a good way, so what do u expect? n she herself is not being optimistic. before u advice anyone here, I think u should advice her first because she started all of these. Why do ppl have to be nice with her when she dont even bother to be nice with ppl? I dont see the logic here. "Saling menegur la sesame kite. Beradab la sikit ye", duhh, that is what these comments are all about. U want ppl to "beradab"? how come? Anisah doesnt show that she is "Beradab" so y ppl need to "beradab" with her?

To arina: u said "xkan lah x leh jadi pro,,be open in accepting critics kayh", do u think that anisah is so pro in this subject? All of us here r not stupid enough to just accept anything that she has to said. n one more thing, I like ur point, u said "u all nie,kalo nk kritik or ambush org pon,bia lah kna pade tempatnye", Anisah herself critics ppl "tak kne pd tempatnya", if she really hates that play, she should just keep it to herself, not posting it to blogs n make everyone who dont even involved in this issue have negative perspective on Benl students. Rite, I dont think ppl who r not involved in this play have the right to criticise the plays because it doesn't counts. Not everyone has the same wicked mind as she has, n her opinions doesn't match with everyone's opinion who had watched the plays.

Finally, to anisah, a so called writer who preach about Islamic values but she hersefl is "ugh" n doesnt even know how to write 'Astagfirullahal'azim', u said "all my haters go under the same name, which is "anonymous", I agree with Forensic-Linguist-To-Be that they must all come from a small number of people", just a little grammatical error here, it supposed to be "they must all come from a big, very big, (u urself cant imagine how big it is) number of people". To prove how mentally retarded n psychopath u r," Btw, you guys, you don't have to feel sorry for me, K? I'm having the time of my life, reading these comments!". This shows how pathetic u r, u gained a lot more sympathies from all of us, this is actually a way for u to get ppl to notice u rite? U dont have any friends to talk to n listen to ur crappy talks, so by posting this, ppl would actually notice u, o.. how pathetic. Its shockening that u r "having the time of ur life", how wicked, just admit that u actually love it when ppl just hates u. aren't u?

p/s: Actually its "the downfall time of ur life"

anisah shurfa said...

I am ready to enlighten you, for I too am amused :)

you guys are committing the fallacy of stereotyping. do you know each and every one of benl students to say that "benl students" love western things? just because some of them are, doesnt mean the rest of them are too.

Absolutely true. I know many perfectly wonderful Benl students who are not obsessed with Western things.

you say that Anisah is commenting on the play, not the people in it. excuse me, did she not comment on the fashion sense of the lead actress? what is that? what she wore was just a costume for the play, and it does not reflect her fashion sense. i see you wear outfits like that sometimes.

Actually, I commented on the fashion sense of the character, not the actress. I know that it is a costume for the play. Thus I am free to critisise it as it is a part of the play, not something personally involving the actress herself. I referred to her as Fashion Victim Wife, not Fashion Victim [insert actress's name here]

And yes, I do wear skirts and blouses like that. But one man's meat is another man's poison, if you know what I mean. It is the wardrobe people's responsibility to make sure their actors' look their very best on stage. So maybe you can improve on that next time? :-)

is anisah credible enough to comment/'review' the plays?

I watched the play til the end, and I had my opinions about it, which I posted here. End of story. Must a person be a musician or music expert to decide whether they like a band or not?

does she know what Lysistrata is all about?

No, I didn't. And since you were screening that drama, I expected you to enlighten me. Don't worry, I got the gist of it.

the disease portrayed by the woman in the second play is a type of psychological disorder. psychology students learn it. isn't that kinda the same?

Same as what?

there are actually a few lessons to be derived from the 2nd play if you really paid attention anisah.

That's good! :) Congrats for conveying those good messages, really. Unfortunately, as an audience member, I failed to notice the messages until you pointed it out to me. Why? Because I was so bored I couldn't be bothered to pay enough attention to that scene. Why not convey the message in a way that audience will definitely pay attention towards it?

is it okay to spread lies and slander now?

No, it's not okay. Which is why some people claiming that they see me "pagi petang malam berdua je" with my boyfriend is unacceptable. That is lying and slander. Accusing me of being "a naive, immature,desperately seeking attention nobody" and "trash-talking attention-whore" is lying and slander. Like someone said in a previous comment, "don't you know that hurting people's feeling is sinful? and once you do it, you HAVE to beg EACH one of them for forgiveness? or else ALLAH will no longer shower His mercy on you.
do think about it."

Now, tell me where I wrote slander and lies in my post, and I'll explain to you why I wrote it.

i do not see the constructive criticism in this post. maybe just a little.

It's okay if you don't see it. I get it that you were too angry at being mocked at to see what I was saying.

anisah shurfa said...

To Rye:

I dont think ppl using 'anynomous' is coward, if they do, they dont have the guts to write here.

What's so brave about writing mean stuff to people without revealing your identity? By going anonymous, it means you're too cowardly to face the repercussions of your actions.

To quote a previous comment: *duh moment*

u said "all my haters go under the same name, which is "anonymous", I agree with Forensic-Linguist-To-Be that they must all come from a small number of people", just a little grammatical error here, it supposed to be "they must all come from a big, very big, (u urself cant imagine how big it is) number of people".

No, I didn't make a grammatical error when I failed to say "big, very big" instead of "small". That's not even grammar!

And why don't you guys prove to me how "very big" you are by coming up to me or commenting with your true identity? Then I'll actually believe that.

she hersefl is "ugh" n doesnt even know how to write 'Astagfirullahal'azim'

I never said I was perfect, my dear. Yeah, I know I am an abysmal speller. And so are you. Sigh.

if she really hates that play, she should just keep it to herself, not posting it to blogs n make everyone who dont even involved in this issue have negative perspective on Benl students.

Honestly? It was the comments from the Benl students involved in the production crew that gave negative perspective on Benl students. It's very sad.

***

I could go on and on, but I'm getting sleepy. Salam and goodnight, everyone! :-)

Forensic Linguist to-be said...

I'm going to print this and publish as my thesis research, dudes! Absolute gold! Love it to bits. Thanks all for giving me delicious ideas. Wait, do I have all your permission (all 12 (original) of you?)

Amnah said...

To Rye: Erm...dear, I think you sort of missed the points of my 2 comments. But it's okay. Never mind :-)

Anonymous said...

I'll be back but for now, I'm just gonna leave you this one little comment for you and your shallow mind to think about.

For someone who strongly upholds the Islamic ways of life, you sure have a very "polite" and "Islamic" way of giving a review. Kudos for your choice of words. I can tell your English is excellent. Even we didn't think about using "f*uck" and "holy macaroni" in our plays by actually meaning it. You are aware that "holy macaroni" didn't derive from Islamic culture right?

FYI, we were just acting. Perhaps you lack the knowledge in theater so, why don't you just go and continue commenting on your petty attention-seeking life.

janedoe said...

to Rye: Hello.
the highlight of "I don't think commenting/bashing/mocking anisah using 'anonymous' is a brave act" is not abt the act of commenting/bashing/mocking, but the braveness of tunjukkan diri yg sbena drpd gune anonymous. itu je.
Berani ke seseorang itu bila die menggunekan identiti lain utk mengkritik seseorang?
first misunderstanding.

Maksud sy bile mengatekan "I cant help but see it as you hating Anisah, not her writing, and you are not actually defending the plays, but rather criticising Anisah sbb diri dia" adelah, dr ape yg sy lihat dan fhm, orang yg criticise die pasal topik ni sbb diorg ade personal issue dgn Anisah, and this topic is a platform for them to shoot her non stop. cube fhmkan ayat sy betol2. it goes to everyone and anyone, and even myself, when i said, tolak tepi bende lain.
Second misunderstanding.

Memang posts dari Anisah sgt straightforward, and to the point that boleh jadi rude, but really, perlu ke balas balik ape yg die buat? Kalau orang mengate kite, perlu ke kite mengate die blk? Fikir2kanlah. Kalau die kasar, ape slhnye menegur atau defend dgn care yg lebih baik, yg bkn mcm care Anisah? Sy tak defend sape2, sile faham betol2. Tak sangke awak lebih suke mengamalkan, kalau org tak beradab ngn kite, buat ape kite nak beradab dgn die. Awak rase, bagus ke bende tu?
Third misunderstanding.

I'm not trying to defend anyone here, but giving my opinion generally. Sorry for the misunderstandings caused. :)

And Rye, you misunderstood few comments, but nevermind
:)

Anonymous said...

Just wanna say something..
Sarah Iqbal said that this is ansah syurfa blog so she can write whatever she want... but the drama that night is not hers too so if she hate the drama so much she can just get her ass out of hall...

oooo... with her boyfriend of course... well why did she stay???... questionable??? maybe wanna give support to the ex-gf of his boy who actually play in one of the scene... huhuhu that is so funny cause from what i heard she didn't like her that much lol!!!...

Sorry anisah for noy being rude...

Btw... ur appologizing doesn't seem like it at all u're actually defending and explain or should i say making out a summary out of this mess lol!!1

Haris said...

Haha, kelakar gile la anonymous kat atas ni. best betul aku baca.

Ex-gf bf anisah ada dlm play tu? Perlu ke bring that up. Nampak sgt u all ni ada personal issues dgn anisah.

Let's all hug and make friends. Tapi best gak baca komen2 anonymous ni. Macam tgk high school drama.

Serious best giler, aku tak tipu. Keep it up!

Anonymous said...

okay.. I'm back.
I know it may seem like I'm a coward to put my name under 'anonymous' but I have my reasons.

Anyhoo, first and foremost,I understand that everyone has different opinions. Clearly, yours tend to seem very narrow minded. You don't seem to understand that not everyone working on these plays come from the same background and have the same mind set. I'm pretty sure some of them might have somewhat the same opinion as you do too but they don't diss it mindlessly because they need to do this to pass the course. But that doesn't make them unislamic.

I think your action for judging the BEN students to be unislamic is very shallow. It's just a play. Who are you to judge them based on a play? You don't even know half of these people. You wanna criticize, criticize on the performance. Bab2 unislamic tolonglah jangan sentuh. Are you such a perfect person that you actually have the rights to judge people in such ways?

And about the suicidal scene on the play. You're saying that it's a sin for her to do so. But so what? It's just a play. You seem to be mad when people criticize about your wrong doing for lingering around with your boyfriend. Same goes for the people who produced the play. They KNOW it's a sin, but they're NOT actually doing it kan? It's called reality anisah. It happens in life and that's what they tried to convey. If you expect people to keep it in the dark and a close mind about it, sampai bila la Melayu tak berkembang. Even IIUM doctors and councelors don't judge these people to be unIslamic. It's an illness. Sin or no sin, it's not your place to judge. Itu antara dia dengan Tuhan.

The world is not perfect anisah, especially from an Islamic perspective. So why don't you open your eyes and accept these differences. If you are so anti-western culture and beliefs, I suggest that the next time you write an assignment, don't make references from a western scholar. That way you won't be Islamically biased. True? Tapi, bila tulis paper, depend on wastern references jugak kan? When you're dissing people, you seem to highly enjoy cussing the "western" way. I find that ironic.

You're a joke.

Nazriq said...

Whoa, I can't believe this is going on and on... This situation is making me so embarrased to admit I'm a BENL student. I'll post my take on the play once I'm done with my assignments...

Once again, I repeat: I'M A BENL STUDENT. I don't feel insulted at all about this post (it's a fun read to be honest, though it is very harsh at first, too) but I feel insulted, embarrased, disgusted and ashamed of what my own coursemates are doing and how are they reacting towards JUST A SINGLE POST. GET A LIFE. Criticisms are bound to be anywhere. Try being in KAED, where everything you do is based around CRITICISMS. We learned to live with that, plus I WAS a KAED student, so I definitely know what I'm saying.

ANYWAY...

@Alyaa: PLEASE do not commit fallacy of association. Besides, just because I'm connected to Anisah doesn't mean I agree with her. You didn't even read the whole post or my comment. Hope you do read before commenting

@anonymous number don't-know-what and Haris:

Not to be rude, but the so called ex-gf of mine in the play was NEVER, I repeat, NEVER my girlfriend ever, and never was. Hope that is incredibly clear. The only reason I was there was because
1. I'm a BENL student, I want to support my coursemates
2. I want to derive new ideas so when it's my turn to write a drama, I have something to look up to.

Shame on you BENL students, you make me feel a lot of regret for changing to BENL. Sigh.

End note: BENL students who are coming up with the most immature comments I've seen ever, I have a few things to say:

1. Has it ever crossed your thoughts that a BENL LECTURER maybe reading and assessing this whole blog post? With all your comments, don't you think your comments could be a bit... incriminating?

2. Being anonymous is weird in this situation. If you're so proud of your production, why can't you put your name to it? Why? Please tell me why. Plus, if you think you all can get away with it, perhaps you forgot the fact that we learn LINGUISTICS and courses such as CRITICAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS and the like. Meaning, tracing identities and fake ones are ridiculously... easy...

Beats me, really.

But I have to say, in some way, everything here is funny. One post can make "40+" people react as if it's the end of the world?

There are better things to care about. War, famine, and the such.

Ponder back on your actions, BENL production crew.

::vOgUe:: said...

Okie dokie lets clear this matter up people... lets have peace...

to all the commenters i know some of you are angry but i think you guys should just stop here... cause it will only cause more trouble... Realize that people make mistakes, and mistakes made to be corrected

aND TO ANISAH just admit that you're rude and apologize..it's not like killing you to apologize... what it is hard for you to do so... live with it sis... you said by leaving comments will make people look stupid... well how about those people no offense but like you make mistakes but feel fear to apologizes to me they seem the same stupid and lame... so as a matter of facts as long as you're not apologizing you're also stupid!!!... don't you think so...

And to those who agree with her, u're not making anymore improvement between her and the commenters... by giving an idea to ANISAH that the commenters are stupid is not gonna help lol!!!...

Besides, people there are bigger things that we need to deal with out there... and let me remind you that final is just around the corner... in 1 week time so let work our butt off for it...

break your leg bitches!!!... huhuhu...

oopppsss!! many2 sorry bitches is the word I use for people... don't get angry people... chill... smile...

i come to make peace...

bye... adios... arrivederci...

luv,
vogue

::vOgUe:: said...

btw... sorry for the grammar... kinda dizzy rite now... erm... the what is actually why... huhuhu...

Anonymous said...

hmm .. mmg bodoh dan bangang la kau .. seriously .. anisah .. u r an ugly lady (xmo lbh2, nti nangis ko sorg2 ngn bf ko) .. xreti nk menilai .. i hope one day, god teaches u wht life is ..

anisah shurfa said...

Oh... the comedy..

Vogue, I did apologise already for hurting people's feelings. It's in the comments. But I'm not surprised if it was overlooked, due to the remarkable amount of people who have come in full force to diss me, support me, or take on a neutral stance. (Unless it's just 12 people, as Forensic-Linguist-To-Be says. LOL!) I know my review is rude and harsh, and that the only redeemable fact about it is that I never crossed the line to personally attacking the actors. *shrugs*

To the anonymouses who keep commenting on an on and on, I can't be bothered to say anything anymore, because I, my sisters and some other people have already said things in the comments that refuted your argument before you even wrote it. It just shows you're not going to read it, so I won't waste my time here.

But there's at least two comments I'd like to clarify upon before I go off to eat:

I think your action for judging the BEN students to be unislamic is very shallow.

I didn't say Ben students are shallow and unislamic. Please read my post carefully before accusing me of such nonsense. I would never say such a thing, considering my sister was a ben student and currently a ben lecturer, my other sister is a ben student (though in another uni) and my own boyfriend is in Ben.

What I said was the play was unislamic. Get your facts straight.

Also, stop saying "it's just a play", and reread Madam Azimah's comment regarding your responsibilities as a BEN student of IIUM in performing plays.

To Forensic-Linguist-To-Be: Feel free to use this for your thesis research, dude. In fact, you can even interview me through email, and I can explain to you why these girls have such a personal grudge against me ;-)

Akmal Azeman said...

hey thr! i was formerly a science stdnt, had been 1 since almost 4 years ago. bt i recently received a 'hidayah' to do ben. honestly speaking, while i was in my matriculation years, i once attended a drama competition. i was so excited about it since like u said, it sounded so cool. kan? as it turns out that half of the girls took advantge of that, 'costume'ly speaking; they took the opportunity to put on clothes that is absolutely not appropriate for our uni. in other words, they'r being syok sendiri. so dat nyte, i was feeling the same way as u did on that drama nyte, bt mayb u punye lg terok kot? huhu. benl stdnts should stop being syok sendiri whnvr they wanted to stage sumting. we all need to think out of the box.

p/s: thank God i missed the whole thang. eheh. :p

Anonymous said...

Honestly,

If I were a BEN/BENL(cause different people call it differently) I would just let go.

This is a graded performance right? Get your grades and be happy la. Her review is not gonna affect your grades. Heck, from one of the comments it was implied as "an unwanted review" even.

I'm not even supporting Anisah here cause I don't even know her... but the influx of angry anonymous (I'm a neutral anonymous) is just plain embarrassing for ben students.

I don't even know why you guys bother. Doesn't seem like her blog gets high traffic (well, before this review of course) and to be perfectly honest... yes, it was entertaining. But after reading the review, I didn't think that ben students did a bad job. In fact, it just made me wish I had seen it so I can make my own judgement about it. Just like what you expected from people watching the play... you perform and let them make whatever they want to make out of it.

However, kids crying in shows are predictable. They're kids and they're supposed to sit and be quiet for a few hours like DUH!

But then again, as someone wrote, this is just Anisah's point of view. Does it matter if she doesn't get this "effing" masterpiece? Does it matter that she has a bf? Totally blown out of proportion.

Had to use an anonymous, sorry.

Jom MinOm MiLo said...

haha..
yg jaoh kte dekat kan..
yg dekat kte rapat kan..
yg rapat kte erat kan..
yg erat,kte nk watpe ea..

haa..kte besatu la..
yg lepas kte lupe kan ye..
sume org ade wat silap..

yg penteng kte pebaiki..
jgn la gado2..
kalo keleng ngn melayu,xpon cine ngn melayu..
ok gak..ni sesame sedare..

harap,sume lupe kan ape yg belaku k..
just maap kan sume yg ade wat salah..
ok..?yg penteng..
nek kan nme islam k..
jgn turon kn..

4JJI huakbar..!!
peace no war..
smile.. :)

alzulkifli said...

salamalaikum...

phew anisah you've really spiked the 'war' haha, congratulations. the effect is almost similar to the the assasination of the arhcduke franz ferdinand LOL!

as a former student of BENL, and now a lecturer i'll try to be 'un-judgemental'.

i guess to write something and post it online requires a lot of courage huh? kudos to you for being straightforward and honest. however, let me remind you that these two qualities are sometimes or perhaps most of the time not appreciated. nevertheless, it should not deter you from practicing them. experience will teach you how to balance these qualities with other equally good traits.

regarding the play, i agree that plays presented by any Muslim (with special regards to IIUM students) should represent the islamic qualities that make us different from others. however, not watching it with my own naked eyes, i dare not give any critical review ;).

i just want to remind everybody that you don't need controversial stuff to stand out in the crowd. there are so many other ways to gain and sustain attention. trust me, i am a teacher hahaha.

i think we need to open up to criticism, it helps us to be better and learn faster. if we only want to hear the good stuff, we'll drown when reality hits us. although it's kinda hard to accept criticism, we should teach ourselves to see the positive side of it.

last but not least, there are many types of fallacies that one can use in his or her argument. however, fallacy can never be the basis of a strong argument. so stay away from committing this 'crime'.

(what is fallacy? - ha go search the term in critical thinking field)

anisah, keep posting your thoughts but keep in mind that sometimes we can churn the negativity into something inspiring and positive. how to do that? you shall find the answer as you grow older like me hehehe...

to fellow benl students, orang melayu cakap - jangan cepat melatah. i remember Prof. Quayum's advice to our class few years ago, if one or two people do not like your work, it does not represent the whole bunch of people who have read or seen it. it's just the opinions of ONE or TWO people. jadi janganlah cepat melatah dan terimalah teguran dengan baik. it's far much easier to practice husnu zahn (sangka baik) rather than squeezing your brain cells thinking how to get back at your critic.

relax and have fun. university life doesn't last long. so enjoy it while you can.

remember, churn the negative qi into positive ones.

all best!

Hana said...

To Anisah, u said "And why don't you guys prove to me how "very big" you are by coming up to me or commenting with your true identity? Then I'll actually believe that".

R us sure u want us to come to u? r u truly sure? Because we r actually planing to meet u anytime soon, just be prepared ya. Maybe u should bring a spare panty because u might be "peeing n pooping" at the same time when u see how big we r. N a lot of tissues too.. c you looser, time moves fast, just be ready, we r coming, dont u worry, then u will see "how very big we r"!

TO Nazriq, "Anisah's male version", they truly suites each other rite guys?.. Both of them r loosers in UIA since they dont have any friends n only have each other. Guys, its okay that they r always be with each other all the time, u guys should understand that they just dont have anyone else who wants to hang aroung with them.. Poor couple, just let them be..
U said "well I feel insulted, embarrased, disgusted and ashamed of what my own coursemates are doing and how are they reacting towards JUST A SINGLE POST. GET A LIFE.".
FYI Nazriq, we all BENL students felt the same way. We all feel insulted, embarrased, disgusted and ashamed of YOU. U too should get a LIFE. U said, "Shame on you BENL students, you make me feel a lot of regret for changing to BENL. Sigh."
So tell us, why do u change to BEN in the first place? WHY? We dont even welcome u to BEN. If u feel ashamed, then get the hell out of BEN! Why do u change ur course in d first palce? Then u r really stupid, n if u still stay in BEN, then, shame on u. We hope that u will suffer as long as u r in BEN. Just change back to ur course dude, we dont even want to see ur face and admit that u r our coursemate. U r rite that "There are better things to care about. War, famine, and the such.", then why dont u tell that to ur boss since u r her pet.

To janedoe, u said "Memang posts dari Anisah sgt straightforward, and to the point that boleh jadi rude, but really, perlu ke balas balik ape yg die buat? Kalau orang mengate kite, perlu ke kite mengate die blk? Fikir2kanlah. Kalau die kasar, ape slhnye menegur atau defend dgn care yg lebih baik,". u tak paham ke "WHAT GOES AROUD COMES BACK AROUND"?? Thats life man, u should accept that. The BEN students actually never notice her existence n never "mengate" her so y does she have to post this harsh comments on them?


ANISAH, I WANT TO ASK YOU: WHY DO U POST THIS BLOG IN THE FIRST PLACE? WHY? WHY DO YOU HAVE TO TELL THE WHOLE WORLD ABOUT HOW DISGUST U R WITH THEIR PLAYS? AND Y DO YOU HAVE TO HUMILIATE THEM?

Hana said...

Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author.



HOW COWARD U R! SHAME ON YOU! WHAT A LOSER! SCARED RITE? HAHAHA... We'll meet u anytime soon Anisah, just be prepared. Tick tock tick tock, the time is ticking, u cant run, u cant hide, we are going to find u. maybe tomorrow, maybe todat, maybe right now, just be ready. U asked for it, u got it.. Maybe this is the only way to teach u a little lesson to mess up with us..

C you later loser! cant wait to meet YOU!

Anonymous who asked you questions, which you answered said...

hello again. thank you anisah for entertaining me.

firstly, i agree with rye on daus' comments. HOW do you know she wasn't spreading lies? were you there?

i do see the constructive criticism behind your c/rude discourse.
Zeus could've been changed to Oh God or something. other than that...it's quite vague. i wasn't aware your review is a piece of poetry. geddit?
i'm sorry the wrong emotions were conveyed to you through my comment. if words can speak their own voice, you would hear that it is with a neutral heart i write this.

in psychology, do people not learn about this disorder? in higher levels it is taught with details, even to the point of showcasing the actual video of a person with the disease in the act. i was told this by prof hariyati abd majid, former head of psyc dept in iium, in one of her talks. now won't you agree it is kind of the same?

well, if you fail to notice those messages, which were quite obvious, it was your fault. before you review something you should pay attention to every single detail of it. or at least the whole of the lines in the play in this case. instead, you go saying that the play does not contain any morals, when in fact it was because of your shortcomings you missed them. you called the character the voice of reason. why, might i ask? you must have heard her lines. did it not convey anything? or were they merely "there"?

true, but liking is a different thing. but one a non-musician/music expert comment on the sound of the instruments, or the vibrato/falsetto of the singer's voice, would his comments be credible? i see your point though.

isn't fashion sense an individual right? how does the fashion sense relate to the quality of the drama?
as you say, one man's meat is another man's poison. i notice that some people that i know always attack a person's fashion preference. does it hurt your eyes so much? why can't some people just leave other people and their clothes be? in the uk nobody would care what you wear. no one even looks in your direction even if you wear pajamas with heels n toga. it's really not a big deal.
but tell me, what impression did you get of the fashion victim wife, as you call it, by her clothes? just want to know whether the right impression was thrown.

about Lysistrata, i think i would understand why you didn't get the play by its essence. the play was not staged in the entirety of the script. and as you say, the lead actress spoke too fast, probably you missed some essential lines. there, i found another constructive criticism in your post.

you tell people to get their facts straight. did you bother to do that? i really don't know how you perceive a pizza cutter anisah.
and the title of the play, once again, it was your shortcomings that led to it. or maybe the mc's voice was too slow. i don't know, but i did hear the title of the play. it was enigma.

i do agree that some commenters are being emotional and so their judgments are clouded. i think that's because of your misunderstanding + your incredible string of words that would leave Gordon Ramsey agape. if i'm not mistaken Prophet Muhammad said if you have nothing nice to say, then say nothing.

the Lysistrata programme book was written by (i think it's safe to say) an incompetent benl student who did not carry out her responsibilities to the crew well. do not go stereotyping all benl students for her mistake. but the programme book could've been proofread first.

well, it is nearing the end of the semester. maybe everyone should cool down and hope for the best (the plays get good marks).

Anonymous said...

Senang cita kan, sume tak nak ngaku kalah. Masing2 nak betul je. Dah la... it's only a bloody blog.

and yes anisah, you didn't judge secara straight forward yang BENL students are unislamic but your words trigered everyone else to think so. words can be easily misinterpreted just like how the BENL plays were misinterpreted. thanks to your brilliant words, BENL dapat title for being unislamic. padahal kat uia tu berlambak je students yang buat keja tak senonoh (and they aren't specifically BENL students JE). never the less you guys seriously should get over this. No need to get so emotional about it.

anisah shurfa said...

I published these comments in case I die. ;)

Let's meet up on Tuesday at 5.30pm then, at Evoke i Cafe, along with Bro Shahrul Anuar and Mdm Rohani, to keep things in control. :)

Akmal Azeman said...

huh. how shallow can u get kan anisah? pfftt!

y change to benl?? i just converted myself to benl n its all out of passion that i've been carrying for YEARS even though i heard so many rumours about benl stdnts n i was a bit takot in the beginning to tukar huhu. teguran is always good. i once involved in a play back in IIUM kuantan campus, at kulliyah of science n it received quite a heavy critism. it was not islamic as the seatings were freeseatings (bros n sis duduk campor2). i was one of the leading actresses, the biggest mistake i did was putting on a sumwat body fitting outfit n i received quite a blew on it. the more time passes by, the more i heard how unislamic the play was. then how did we dealt wit it? well. we'r trying to improvise it day by day...at least thy r still improvising the concept n all, since im already in gombak.

anyway. takyah lah nk start a fight n jumpe. buruk perangai. we hv to rmmbr, kt smua da adults so we should learn to accept critism. malu mmg malu bt every actions n decisions hv its own consequences. kan?

p/s: perhaps anisah, mayb ur approach is slightly off?? huhu. just an opinion lah.

cheers! :)

lisa said...

wow.
harsh.

watch ur back anisah.
you are in biggg trouble.

bro. kamal said...

ya tuhan. tak abis-abis lagi?

Dah dah la tu. benda dah jadi.

let it go saje ok?

gaduh-gaduh pun tak ke mane.

anak pak man said...

ya know what's more entertaining than the blog post?
the epic drama that has ensued!
why oh why am i not a UIA student??


btw anisah, some people ah, just aren't open-minded at all.. It's the world we're living in, and there's no easy escape route..
all the best for you Anisah Shurfa.. Be strong..

IIUM's said...

Anisah said:
"Let's meet up on Tuesday at 5.30pm then..."

good idea babe.
i can't wait to see the full stop for all these.

let's make PEACE =)

Alyaa said...

Nazriq please put your assumptions aside aite, I did read the post lah. I'm just too lazy to comment about the content like 'em people. Leave it to them to do that.

And that's just MY opinion, kan? Takkan tu pun tak boleh, come on. I were merely stating my thoughts but if that's too much then pardon me for commiting such a fallacy. I'm just being frank with you.

I cannot believe dah sampai 115 comments. Wows.

aida cy said...

ok..
anisah.
this is aida..
as usual..
to many words in a post for a dork like me :p
since im not a BEN stud or ever learning play..
im just passing by and say im here for u
hehe..
harsh words arent they, the comment..
well..lets lunch or dinner together2 with others to cheer u up..
whatever now

pls mind the grammar n spelling errors ;p

Jem said...

WHOAH. a hundred and fifteen. thats awesome.

I've always love your reviews.

Have anyone of you read her review on 5 Jingga? The actress herself just took the review professionally.

Take it as a critism and improve yourself. Not bash Anisah.

This thing going on here, is SO HIGH SCHOOL.

and I thought I'm moving forward instead of backward.*sigh*

Ziera said...

ponder on this one please~

” don’t you think those who critisize because they concern and those who support because they love?”
Both parties are good but express their feelings in two different ways..
even if it’s not true, thinking about this make you feel better isn’t it? can u?

my ustaz once said,
‘nafsu comprises 7 different stages ranked form the lowest to the highest.
the lowest called ‘amarah’ follwed by ‘mutmainnah’ and..(I already forgot the other five stages but the highest four can only be obtained by ‘rasul’, ‘nabi’, ‘wali’ and ‘alim ulama’ )

‘amarah’ is the worst - satan-oriented leads by anger and other bad values.

‘mutmainnah’ obtained by those who always reflect upon their behaviour (both bad and good). willing to beg for forgiveness for any wrong doings and willing to forgive others for their mistakes.

and the other one (forgot its name) obtained by those who never think bad about others despite any circumstances.

those three can always be obtained by us, normal people (not only muslim) but try to avoid the sata-oriented one.

p/s - correct me if i’m wrong. if not, please convey this message.
tq
- i cannot post any comments on your other topics. i
just don’t understand. maybe you should enlighten me first
- Please smile always :D

I got this from my blog. well I think what this person said is totally true. Since we're talking about being Islamic and all, let's just let it be this way.

Akmal Azeman said...

hey girl! u should move forward. write a spanking brand new entry. wat say u? i tink dat would shut everyone up. i mean, its all in d past now n takde thr's no use crying over spilt milk. if thy bring the same old topic again, then thy r all ketinggalan zaman. just ignore them. pfft!

i sokong any honest opinions. y not everyone else???

Jom MinOm MiLo said...

haha..
yg jaoh kte dekat kan..
yg dekat kte rapat kan..
yg rapat kte erat kan..
yg erat,kte nk watpe ea..

haa..kte besatu la..
yg lepas kte lupe kan ye..
sume org ade wat silap..

yg penteng kte pebaiki..
jgn la gado2..
kalo keleng ngn melayu,xpon cine ngn melayu..
ok gak..ni sesame sedare..

harap,sume lupe kan ape yg belaku k..
just maap kan sume yg ade wat salah..
ok..?yg penteng..
nek kan nme islam k..
jgn turon kn..

4JJI huakbar..!!
peace no war..
smile.. :)

arina said...

owh anisah,,this is good,,damn good!...xsgka this post dpt sambutan hangat!mcm adlin aman ramli la pulak kan...people do hate him,but dye pnye critics mmg honest..XD..

and to people who may concern,please dont pick up satu atau dua atau sekerat pon xmpi the sentences from my comment kay untuk menegakkan u all pnye bantahan wlpn u all suke dgn my confession..hehe

once again,this war is really good!mmg boley jadik bahan untuk tesis!XD

and to people yg akn jumpe di evoke, good luck!jgn ganggu mood org nk makan sudah la atau u all pulak yg kena kick out dr cafe,,XD

peace,no war!XD

arina said...

hey!i do not like the word that being used by one of the anonymous..dah la u susah2 open anisah pnye blog,and then u pki anonymous, and then u bg la pulak bodoh n bangang,,tolong la bro or sis,kawan tu xde pon ckp awk mcm tu,yg awk nk terasa sgt nie kenape?awk nie antara pelakon dlm drama tu ker?n kalo anisah tu bodoh n bangan, i rase better u print out u pnye slip exam,pg kat anisah,compare the result..then,baru u boley cakap siape bodoh dan bangang..baru adil,,XD

x backup anisah,tp kalo org yg laen or u sndri dpt title bodoh atau bangang, msti bengang kan?

u the one who need to watch ur words..

arnab superhero said...

omg bosannya tengok orang gaduh2.
alrite ppl. why waste time on this?
go spread some love, peace.
earth day is coming up!
dont forget to switch off
the lights (830-930pm):DDD

Wahidah@wordpress said...

Assalamualaikum....

Pizza cutter! To kill yourself! Heeelarious!

So many pissed off people you got here, Anisah. BTW, we were practically neighbours in TTDI but I'm taking Nutrition in Nottingham, UK. Just to be clear who I am here so that the new rule you just implied does not apply to me. I was in CFS, but after my finals escaped at the first opportunity I got. No offense and no ungrateful-ness intended.

Come on people, it was just a review. Everyone's entitled to have his/her own opinions, no matter how harsh. What's wrong with being honest? If it was Mr. Cowell would have been hung a long time ago.

When you are brave enough to produce anything that is controverSIAL and would no doubt set tongues wagging, you have to be brave enough to accept criticism. Plus, IIUM is THE Islamic University of Malaysia, as it claims so often to be, so I would have thought a play like this wouldn't have been approved to be viewed by a large audience, much less kids. Poor kids needed consoling after watching it. Wouldn't that be indication enough that the play was that bad?

And some are calling the language here crude? Try living in a dormitory in the UK. Though I love it so here.

Peace, Anisah, and keep up the good work. Wasalam.

atirah said...

btw idiot, you're not watching so don't give any comment. it's not a pizza cutter. i think the stupid writer can't see it properly. it's a canting batik. kalau pakai pisau betul karang, terkejut plak. anyway, kitorg sume dah x kesah pon psl nih. it's just banyak benda yg die tulis x betul dan ramai yang TAK TENGOK percaya.it's a FITNAH. saying sumthing which is not true. and you know dosa fitnah seberat mana. writer, to prove your harsh words upon our play, why don't u post some pictures of the play so that people who DO NOT see can judge. and if you're really sorry writer, post it BIG on your blog. not among the comments where ppl may overlook so that we all can see that you're really sorry. thats all. tq

unokhan said...

o lawd! way too many comments for me to read here. islamic theater n indo-asia sounds like euro theater n the sixties-- honee, enjoy it while it lasts.

that was a good review -- made my stomach smile

atirah said...

actually, we accept your critics. we are OK with it.it's OK if you don't like the play but wut we are not Ok with is that you spread fitnah. you saying things which are not true. first of all, sape invite ko dtg? xde org pon kan?? play kitorg for family, classmates and friends. are you a friend? DON'T THINK SO. usher to lead you the way? helloooo..this is class presentation. bukannya theater club grand play. wut do you expect after that? food and refreshment after the play?? wrong facts written by you: pizza cutter? its a canting batik. wearing sumthing from not to wear? we wear clothes following the dress code. non of us show our aurat. even the greek play use dark inner inside to cover their aurat. parents have to console their children?? my god! ko tau x parents sape yang ko maksdkan tu? parents kawan kitorg kot."I swear, a parent was even heard consoling her young children, insisting that none of it was real." tolong lah jgn BOHONG. you were sitting in the middle. parents were sitting way behind you. how can you see it?? how can you even heard it?? you came out early. how do you know?? kalau ko xtau ape pon psl play kitorg, PLEASE ask us first before nk kritik kitorg. jgn tulis fitnah! people who write reveiew,first of all dorg mesti tau wut is that play is all about. you don't even know! then how can you write review based on your own kepala hotak?? you're biased. kenapa x tulis jugak psl poetry slam? knp x tulis jugak psl the other two plays to be fair? knp kritik play kami je?? the MC already gave out moral values after the play. she also did tell wut the play name is and tell a bit about the play. cant you hear them or are you deaf?? it's already been a week. we just don't care about this anymore. we understand if some ppl may like the play and some may not. but plsss dun spread FITNAH. for all of those who didn't even catch the play, TOLONGLAH PLSSS jgn komen ape-ape. korg x dtg tgk pon lansung lepas tu nk kutuk2 kitorg plak based on wut the writer wrote. adil ke tu?? korg lansung x layak nk ckp ape2. bagi yang dah tgk n komen, ok, we accept that sbb korg tgk dgn mata sendiri. klo x tengok dgn mata sendiri lepas tu ckp plak kitorg bukan2, bukan ke korg pon FITNAH kitorg jugak?? think about it.writer, do put pictures of our play or a video so that they can make judgement as well. jgn buat penilaian berdasarkan one person story coz you know NOTHING about it. n plss jgn sokong membuta-tuli. you have brain. think first. just because the writer is your friend or sister or whoever, doesn't mean she's ALWAYS right. thats all. -END-

*if you are brave enuf. post this comment.tq*

Max J. Potter said...

hah. sorry i'm late. been busy.

so. a review. harsher than the one i did for the alaf21 junks. a laughable read. very long, but still amusing. probably dried out a few brains out there into nothingness since the comments they came up with were nonsense.

well. they're what you get for being honest; rotten feedbacks. you're honest. and not many can comprehend that level of honesty. some really small brains would take it as rudeness. and it's easier to take out that disappointment over that inferiority on you than getting into a deep thought comprehending your post. (and i wonder how small are they really, since you weren't writing like shakespeare did, sis.)

truly, pembaris mengukur adab dan kejujuran berbeza antara seorang dengan seorang yang lain. for some, it's as short as the hair they have in their noses. for some others, longer than the time taken to drive from kangar to beseri. thus the different responses.

i won't ask you to choose better/nicer words in your coming reviews. i'm not that choosy in my vocab for reviewing, too. they're pointless; nice reviews. they don't amuse, which is the first thing a review must do. so ah, keep writing and keep that level of honesty.

and dear god my sister is in BENL, and thank you god she wasn't one of the anons. it would've shamed me; the attitude, if she was one.

comment moderation is now on, huh?

and i'm fully OK with it.

Here, *hugs*. you're good.

anisah shurfa said...

Comments are henceforth disabled from this post

Thank you to everyone for taking your time to read and comment on my review :-) Again, I apologise for any feelings that have been hurt from my writings.

The reason I am henceforth disabling comments is because I gave the production crew the opportunity to meet me face-to-face and express whatever is on their mind (as clearly, judging from the comments, there's a lot of pent-up anger going on here). Unfortunately, you didn't take the chance. Too bad.

To everyone else who enjoyed reading my review and found the comments as hilarious as I did, do wait for my upcoming blog post, in which I shall be giving awards to the best comments! Among the categories will be:

Best Comment In A Foreign Language

Most "Insafable" Comment

Most Off-Topic Comment

Best Neutral Comment

and more! :D Stay tuned!